Fishing question regarding different "pulls" and hooksets.

[Paperpickaxe]

if you're using a PS4 controller then it's extremely easy to tell them apart, as a Precision tug is one vibration and a Powerful tug is 2 or 3 Vibrations.

That is the issue the OP is bringing up. When the Ala Mhigan Ribbon hits it gives a pull that seems to merit a Powerful Hookset, but instead requires Precision. On PS4 controller the Ala Mhigan Ribbon gives 2 vibrations but requires Precision.