There is also been a post on these forums with maths included which proves that SCH shield is still stronger then astrologian shield

Aspected benefit is 140 potency that gives a 250% shield.... costs 1440 mp

Adoloquim is 300 potency which gives a shield base on the hp restored and when u crit the shield is doubled.... cost 507 mp... also benefits other skills ... deployment tactics...emergency tactics

Scholar shields cost WAY less then astrologian shield.... ast nearly cost 3x more mp then sch version also scholar can spread it across the raid for 0 mp cost

Problem i see with scholars is that they still trying ti play like they did in hw.... scholat have a solid kit to prevent raid dmg...it dominated ast and whm kit

Indomitability is 400 potency on a 30sec cd.. = 800 potency within 60 sec

Earthly star is 540 potency when used below 10sec.... turns into 720 potency after 10 seconds ... 60sec cd