Scholar and Healing (ignoring the dps aspect)

[Yhisa]

Ughhh

Aspect benefic is 140 base... not 200 ... its 140 in noct sect lol

go back and redo ur math...

ugh i hate using mobile on this .... but ignore that noct sect is 154 potency with noct 10% buff

people neglect that sch can boost there adoloquim with largress... fey illumination.... which is HUGE... se forgot to remove healing buff from fey ilpumination so sch have 40% heal buff

[Xaeth]

The base heal potency of Aspected benefic is 200. The 140 potency is the regen in the Diurnal Sect. In Nocturnal Sect, Aspected Benefic instead gets a 250% shield based on the base heal potency. Also, Nocturnal Sect buffs healing by 15%.
So all in all when not critting Aspected Benefic is stronger than Adlo by 205 potency and when critting, adlo is stronger by 95 potency.
With a crit chance of 10%, Aspected Benefic is about 175 potency stronger on average. For the spells to be equally strong, we need to crit 41 out of 60 times which corresponds to a crit chance of 68%.
Information on Aspected Benefic and Nocturnal Sect was taken from Square Enix's own jobguide on http://eu.finalfantasyxiv.com/jobguide/astrologian/.

[Cynfael]

ugh i hate using mobile on this .... but ignore that noct sect is 154 potency with noct 10% buff

Please read your tooltips carefully before you keep hammering away with your incorrect numbers. Reading the past few pages has been painful.