With RDM getting Vercure, I was really hopeful that Physick would be redesigned to work off INT for SMNs as well. In terms of design, I could see this being a challenge to have it spec differently depending on which job the player has chosen. For this reason, SMNs should get a Physick II that replaces Physick.

Physick II would not change in potency, but would spec off INT and have a higher MP cost to match Vercure.

This is not a tool for playing a 3rd healer in raids, it's an emergency tool/soloing tool, and SMNs need it more than RDMs. This is because of the loss of Sustain. Running around as a SMN and trying to solo FATEs because there aren't enough people in that particular area, Topaz Carby is extremely helpful in not dying to getting attacked by 2 enemies.

Now that I can't heal him with sustain, I've been relying on Erase which is gated by a long cooldown. If I had a Physick II, I could heal my tank pet when necessary rather than need to resummon him in order to keep his HP high.