Physick II for SMN

[Kyeria]

The thing is the basic Physick is a useless action. It's ok in the beginning levels and is good for exposing Arcanists to healing but is out leveled once you pick the Summoner job path. On the higher level NPC's I receive more healing plus get DPS with Drain and Energy Drain. So if it is going to be buffed just for pets why not just remove it and give us back Sustain?

While I agree with you that's probably the better outcome, I doubt they'll do that. Doing what you proposed would require SE to add Physick as a Scholar Job Ability and isn't likely to happen.
I only suggested what I did, because it's an easy tweak that SE would probably be more likely to add.

SMN/SCH suffer from unique issues because they both branch off Arcanist and SE currently has a pretty staunch stance on not altering their shared abilities at this time. What honestly needs to happen is Scholar needs a full redesign and to be separated from Arcanist. In turn, the Arcanist abilities could be reworked to fit SMN specifically while not affecting Scholar and allowing it to grow into its own job. This is an issue way down the line though and only if SE ever removes the class system.

[Mavrias]

Oh yeah? Guess who had a battle raise and cure since 2.0, surely that Red Mage that existed back then ;P
And jokes on you, Tri-bind is better than your Tether! (lol)

Every battle class that chose not to equip their job stone.

[Mavrias]

Alright. I'm game. Which other DPS class has absolutely zero defensive CDs and no ability to heal itself? Physick heals a 100 or two so that doesn't count. Which DPS class has their DPS tied to an NPC that is squishy has all hell? Which DPS class has a super long recast time to get started DPSing again should said pet die? Which DPS classes whole mechanics could be ruined by an untimely death to their pet?

Machinist. And, minus the pet concerns, black mage.

[Ariomi]

Machinist. And, minus the pet concerns, black mage.

Except Black Mage has Manaward. Absorbs all damage upto 30% of the Black Mages health - Summoner has nothing like this.
And Machinist's turret has a 10 second cooldown if it dies normally, it costs no mana/tp to re-summon and is instantly cast on the battlefield. Meaning, as long as your turret lasts 10 seconds, you can instantly summon a new turret with little or no penalty.
If a Summoner's pet dies, it's 2400 mana to re-summon, and has a cast time of 6 second. Summoner literally has to stand around for 6 seconds getting its full damage back. Machinist just shrugs, tosses out a new turret and is good to go.