Quote Originally Posted by Erys View Post
Overhealing should be a penalty because you are wasting mp. Thus not playing right. And I'm not speaking any overheal. I'm talking about 10%+ overheal, which you see A LOT in dungeons.
That's an oversimplification. There are a lot of reasons to overheal that aren't "wasting mp," a few of which were already mentioned. Here's another: as a White Mage, if a fight is about to end I will almost always toss a Cure II on the tank (or anyone who's lost any HP) just to grab a free Lily while we're still in combat. Yes, technically this is a waste of both healing and MP, but my MP will likely be full before the next fight anyway. Meaning this is purely "playing right." A system that penalizes this would be the only thing wrong about it.