New PLD should learn how to use their mp effectly...!!!

[Silver-Strider]

If you werent going oom then you weren't spamming clemency or holy spirit, there isn't much more to it than that. Refresh would hold you high for one or two pulls, not for the dungeon. You don't even have the passive that reduces your mp costs by half yet if I remember right.

Holy spirit doesn't have a lot of use in true aoe, but paladin aoe is pretty crap and it takes a lot of targets to make it worth using eclipse over holy spirit as far as damage is concerned.

Couple of things.
1st: both Holy Spirit and the passive that reduces the cost are unlocked at 64.
2nd: Eclipse is better than Holy Spirit in any pull of 4+ mobs. Using Holy Spirit in those situations is a DPS loss and by the time the numbers are in Holy Spirit's favor, the mobs are already at Death's Doorstep anyway.
3rd: You cannot really spam Clemency or Holy Spirit and still maintain aggro. Yes, Clemency might help for a bit but good DPS will outpace the Emnity generation of it fairly easily and while Holy Spirit hits very hard, it doesn't generate enough Emnity per cast to outpace them either.
4th: Since Royal Authority has been changed to the Riot Blade combo set up, the amount of times I'm using Riot Blade has doubled resulting in more MP returns as well.

I said effectively spamming those skills, as in using it to its max potential without it affecting my role as tank. If I lost aggro because I was spamming Holy Spirit, that wouldn't be very effective now would it?