Question to mages that have played post-update (specifically nukers)

[JTSpender]

If chigoes were strong against thunder and weak to water wouldn't that make them earth element?

Anyway, for the most part I *like* the idea that the elemental wheel is "broken" and it's not just an issue of picking one of your 6 identical effects to cast on the enemy. That said, I was doing a few solo leves, and figgy puddings *were* pretty annoying to beat on CNJ while in earth-mode (absorb earth, super resistant to thunder, so that left first tier aero and blizzard from THM). And I was fighting some toads on THM and could two shot (Thunder + instant Thundara) things a couple levels higher than me.

[Spellbinder]

If chigoes were strong against thunder and weak to water wouldn't that make them earth element?

It was 4 AM and I think I had FFXI elemental wheel on the brain, but you get what I was trying to say. Hehe.