samurai will always be top dps, they threw away all and any party utility, it's what monk should of been, samurai is fine. get used to it.
samurai will always be top dps, they threw away all and any party utility, it's what monk should of been, samurai is fine. get used to it.
What do I do? Everything. I do everything.
Party utility seems more like party dependency.
Nothing demonstrates this visually more than Dragon Sight; it shows the concept of this 'utility' with a visceral tether between two players with a clunky short range and it only working when the two are near each other.
Utility sounds like it is meant to be synergy, where the sum is greater than the parts. If that sum is less than just having non synergistic parts, why bother?
Why do people say silly things like this. They act like "group utility" is some magical priceless benefit that makes a class automatically desirable. Group utility (of the damage buffing variety) has a very specific indirect damage value to it per given encounter. You can't just give ridiculous damage to a class because it has no utility. That additional "selfish" dps needs to be equal to the indirect damage utility the other classes are bringing.
Last edited by MomoOG; 07-02-2017 at 03:13 PM.
yeah that's true got your point in the first way already - never the less it's a mmo not an e-sports league. If you ll be judged and critismed by your static/fc for the cls you want to play -> it's not the right place for you to be, move on and find another : /

I won't be judged nor by my static nor by my fc, but I will be judged by myself first and foremost. It's not elitism nor a bad practice to say: hey, this class sucks right now and it needs this buff or this tweak to make it not a deadweight.
Also I heavily appreciate my time even if I'm a neet, and this makes me appreciate others' time. So when I team up with people I will make sure I do everything that is in my hands to make their time with me worth it. The problem is my class choice is gimping me because dragoon got a terrible roll on gear stats in verity gear, and the class itself doesn't deal acceptable dps nor bring enough utility to compensate for the lack of personal damage.

I feel other classes will get buffs rather than them heroic Samurai. Samurai is a fluid class that isn't broken, why tamper with it?
They should buff Sam a tick more, but make it stationery, everything gets casts times.
Than it can be called the hardest and most rewarding class.
As it is now, it's too strong compared to others, not punishing. It out dps-es others with ease and gets all the buffs.



It irks me a bit that they made SAM like this.
They recognise that MNK (and arguably the two casters) in HW was an issue- the concept of no utility/party synergy didn't work out and made it undesirable (technically also why WHM got left out, no way to properly buff the part, which means no synergy).
And now they pick the same idea that did not workout for over a year- but err on the side of excessive power this time, to the point some utility jobs can't compete (and well, BLM, which isn't that much of utility but I digress).
This is walking on a razor's edge- SAM needs a dps surplus so that it matches almost perfectly the overall utility options. This is very hard to do (and even then there would likely be disagreements- a SAM is "all the eggs in one basket"; if he dies, the SAM party suffers more than the utility-based comp. If by some chance the Astro has to dump a single target card, the SAM comp gets a slight edge. Things like that).
I just secretly hope this is a grand experiment so when 4.1 (optimistic) or 5.0 (realistic) hits, they can make this concept work ingame to everyone's contentment.
There are YT videos of blm and smr doing 4600+ dps and a rdm doing 4500+ so are we gonna need them too or just sam
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.

Reply With Quote





