I'm not trying to look for an easy solution, yes that may be again a quick fix for the current problem. BUT I will counter your argument saying the 1:1 scaling on str for tanks at the moment is too broken to do that. If that were the case then you would pretty much never want to bring a dps into your party and stack tanks. What if I told you with current "best in slot" + a full set of 270 str right side, paladins heal for a base of roughly 11k per clemency. So if you give them HP and that amount of dps and healing, what point would there be to bring any other class?