Thread: Consolidated Scholar 4.0 Feedback Thread

Once they announced Redmage I knew I would switch and keep SCH for the quick queues. While Yoshi-P announced that adding 2-DPS would not hurt queues because healers will still heal and tanks will still tank, that might have been true had they not butchered WHM and SCH. Although, I think WHMs have some solace in Thin-Air, and the devs' acknowledgement of the concerns. So I think while WHM gets shafted with the RNG based Lily system, they have some nice additional skills and a hope that they will receive some tweeking in the future. However, Scholar....nope Scholar in my eyes is unplayable.

I've mained SCH since 2.0 because it was the closest we had in FFXIV to a Redmage, and arguably still the closest the game has to a traditional Redmage. We can buff our allies, debuff our enemies, deal a moderate level of damage, and of course heal, a true Redmage. However, now we have a named Redmage and it looks amazing. With all the buzz surrounding the WHM pounding, I didn't even think about SCH nerfs! This shit caught me by surprise and damn it hurts!
SCH in PVP No...just no.
o Chain Strategem, sweet increased damage on the Target and it does work coupled with the PvP Broil is amazing...oh wait AST has that as well.
o No AoE heals in PvP (AST as well though)...are you kidding me!
o That Fairy Gauge tho.....Really!? So 1 heal gives 5 gauge IF in combat. And the bar depletes so fast that it is only worth summoning her if the gauge is full or near full. Remember in PvP it reduces per tick and per heal, HOLY POPSICLES! -20/tick! Thats max five heals and it takes 10-20 just to summon it!....RIP SCH heals in PvP..although AST doesn't look much better but at least their main mechanic isn't nerfed.
o WHM seems like the defacto heals in PvP now, look at them Assizes AND 1 lily per heal...not on RNG, guaranteed..
But we aren't here to talk about WHM.

SCH in normal content No thanks, I'll just AST if I want to stay a healer
o That MP Management. I think this one everyone else has covered. FeelsBadMan
o Ok, so the class is built for LVL 70 Content great!....Um how am I supposed to run my synced roulettes? Pharos Sirius (NM) was Serious! My FC tank pulled everything first room....nope that didn't work out so well.
o Where is my Miasma II with heavy, so that I can hit the first pull with it and they take a while to catch up to the last group pulled?
o Boring content. Hydalean damn it all. 2 DoTs and a Broil? Good thing I have Energy Drain to keep my MP up.
o Role skills - Lets not beat around the bush here:
- Protect
- Esuna
- Lucid Dream, thanks for this I guess
- E4E, could go in the next one too, but since I have no utility anymore I'll take it.
And the rest are situational.
- Cleric Stance: 5%.......
- Swiftcast: When I need to rez someone yes. Solo, nope, 4-mans...lets hope not
- Break: LOL
- Largesse: I mean, if there is nothing else to put up there and since ADLO is expensive now, sure.
- Surecast: Never needed it pre 4.0
- Rescue: This is the most specific damn skill I have ever seen. LOL
o Dafuq did Stoneskin go? Why I only get one shield now? SCH = Preemptive and Damage Mitigation style healing.
o Excogitation: Ok 30s is really short, I find myself PURPOSEFULLY letting the tank hit 50% just so I had something to use it on. If its a mass AoE, I'm going to INDOM and probably Lustrate the Tank. Excogitation is cool in theory but situational as best.
o Ruin II: shit man, you even took my blind debuff!


Bye SCH, you were fun since 2013, I'll miss you my friend, so many memories. DPS queues here I come!

Originally Posted by Reiryuu

I am not sure SE knows how to balance healers... I wonder if they even play healers in PVE... =/

They most certainly do not know how to balance these classes. At the end of hw the three classes were pretty balanced with whm being slightly weaker. All they needed to do was give whm some raid utility and they would have been fine. But instead they decided to buff ast, which I haven't heard a single ast say they needed that buff, then give them the coolest toys. They then gutted sch in every department and gave whm a dumb system. I tried my whm (though it is only lvl 60) in content that with my sch it was extremely difficult to heal through and I did it with ease. Sure, sch has never been known to be the great healer, but to gut us where we are forced to heal then punish us with bad mp management? Excuse me se did you EVER play sch? One of our main things other than being a damage mitigater (now out shined by noct ast) was being the healer that had a larger mp pool. So now we have a healer class that had a buff that it did not need out doing the other two traditional healing jobs of ffxiv, and healer that can at least heal but is as useful to a raid situation as a wet rag with the added bonus of a clunky system, and a class that no one should be taking anywhere if they are sane. I at least have the added bonus of being a good healer, but my friends who love sch and playing it casually now cannot play sch. It's almost as if we're back to square one of 3.0 only instead of ast being the pos healer, its sch. So I guess come 4.4 we'll finally be balanced with the other two healers.

Can we tweak SCH's dots in any way? The way it was before, you generally casted your dots in the order of longest length to shortest (which was Bio II->Miasma->Bio). As it stands now, you're going to be casting Miasma -> Bio II now because Bio II is instant cast. The problem however is that Bio II is 30s while Miasma is still 24, meaning the timing is all wonky.

Can we either: A) Buff Miasma to 30s uptime, or B) Put Miasma II back in as an upgrade to Miasma to go in corruption mastery (non AoE though), while buffing it to 30s uptime (damage upgrade not too necessary I think). I feel the latter is better because it feels dumb for SMN to jump from Miasma to Miasma 3 just because you wanted us to forget Miasma 2 ever existed.

SMN's dots are both 30s but the misalignment for SCH is driving me nuts.

E: Additionally I fail to see the point of Excogitation. While it would have been extremely useful in heavensward, Stance dancing is no longer a thing and thus, Excogitation just seems like a waste when I have Lustrates right here. It should either have an additional effect, or not cost aetherflow.