Thread: Consolidated Scholar 4.0 Feedback Thread

Originally Posted by amihavingfunyet

Could it possibly be that these abilities are much more usable for 8man content? :thinking:
And if the tank doesn't know how to utilize the buffs you give them it's barely the skill's fault.

LOL it is 100% the skills fault if, in my example, the tank moves a tiny bit one way to avoid an AOE and that breaks the Aetherpact chain yet still sucks down the fairy gauge. Yes, that is 100% the skills fault. Don't be ridiculous.

Originally Posted by NorthernLadMSP

LOL it is 100% the skills fault if, in my example, the tank moves a tiny bit one way to avoid an AOE and that breaks the Aetherpact chain yet still sucks down the fairy gauge. Yes, that is 100% the skills fault. Don't be ridiculous.

Either you need to realize that you shouldn't use the skill when the tank is going to have to move soon or the tank needs to learn to not mindlessly run around.
But yes, please balance all classes around expert roulette and low skill level play.
It can definitly use a buff to its range, but it's far from "useless".

Originally Posted by amihavingfunyet

Either you need to realize that you shouldn't use the skill when the tank is going to have to move soon or the tank needs to learn to not mindlessly run around.
But yes, please balance all classes around expert roulette and low skill level play.
It can definitly use a buff to its range, but it's far from "useless".

Your condescending attitude is all I need to see to realize you're no longer worth responding to.

Have a nice day.

Originally Posted by NorthernLadMSP

Your condescending attitude is all I need to see to realize you're no longer worth responding to.

Have a nice day.

Just a small tip, you can cancel Fey Union again if you notice the tank is running out of range.

Originally Posted by amihavingfunyet

-Snip-

While I agree with most of what you've said, please don't make it out to be a good move. Fey Union is utter Dog Shite.

Ironically I've actually found more use for it in Expert Roulette than I have Omega NM/EX Primals.

Originally Posted by Ghishlain

So, upon doing some quick calculations, even with the changes to Aetherflow, with the implementation of Lucid Dreaming as a cross class SCH's MP restoration kit has actually gotten better. At 960 MP / tick, all healers gain 6,720MP every two minutes. In order for the loss of the 10% MP restoration on Aetherflow to match this, a SCH would need to have 33,360MP which feels pretty crazy to me given my SCH in basically capped gear without melds is sitting at 18,000-ish MP. I know it doesn't speak to the other concern of how MP costs for the SCH kit has gone up as a whole but it's a small blessing at least for the loss of the 10% restoration on Aetherflow.

MP regen isn't in a vacuum though. If you doubled a class's MP regen and at the same time doubled their spells MP costs then relatively nothing changed. While Sch may have a tad better MP regen now (at lower MP values) they also spiked the price of Aldo as well.

On the other hand, other healers already had cheaper spells to compensate for their lower MP regen, but now got MUCH better MP regen to go along with those cheaper spells.

Basically while looking at just the MP regen Scholar is near the same, but in practice Scholar is now more expensive while other healers got massively cheaper.

Originally Posted by Supersun

MP regen isn't in a vacuum though. If you doubled a class's MP regen and at the same time doubled their spells MP costs then relatively nothing changed. While Sch may have a tad better MP regen now (at lower MP values) they also spiked the price of Aldo as well.

On the other hand, other healers already had cheaper spells to compensate for their lower MP regen, but now got MUCH better MP regen to go along with those cheaper spells.

Basically while looking at just the MP regen Scholar is near the same, but in practice Scholar is now more expensive while other healers got massively cheaper.

Hence my comment of:

Originally Posted by Ghishlain

I know it doesn't speak to the other concern of how MP costs for the SCH kit has gone up as a whole but it's a small blessing at least for the loss of the 10% restoration on Aetherflow.

According to Live Letter, many changes coming in 4.05. Listed adding Miasma II back, increases in range (nothing specific noted), decreases in cooldown (nothing specific noted), and made it sound like there's many others.

Grat's guys you cried hard enough for them to make SCH OP :P Time to ride the easy train through savage