Cross Class Skills for PLD?

[Mnemosynia]

I'm skipping Provoke. I think it's better to learn to manage my threat than rely on a gimmick that only puts me 1 point above someone else and then hope nobody attacks that thing until I can... manage my threat anyway...

Low Blow - an off GCD interrupt is vital.
Rampart - damage mitigation
Convalescence - alternative path to mitigation
Reprisal - alternative path to mitigation
Ultimatum - temporarily on the bar to 'play around with it' in the open world since all I'm doing in this game is spamming Raubahn anyway...

I am debating putting in Awareness or Anticipation once I had gotten the 'fun' out of spamming Ultimatum in fates.

In any tank swap content, I would like use Shirk... for when I'm wanting to not be the active tank... to force threat onto the other tank.

I don't think you have tanked any decently hard content in your entire life my friend if your saying that.

[Makeda]

I don't think you have tanked any decently hard content in your entire life my friend if your saying that.

I've been an MMO tank since 2005. I've very rarely needed taunt mechanics. A real tank keeps threat, and knows how to get snap aggro. When mechanics specifically call for a taunt swap - I might use it. But only if it actually also holds threat for some length of time while you gain it off the other tank, or resets the other tank's threat for an amount of time.

Otherwise it's a gimmick skill.

It is much more useful to have good skills for damage mitigation.

All provoke does it put you 1 point of threat above whoever was at top. There are a dozen other ways to get there - that are also likely to keep you there.

[SuperGandhi]

I've very rarely needed taunt mechanics. A real tank keeps threat, and knows how to get snap aggro. When mechanics specifically call for a taunt swap - I might use it. But only if it actually also holds threat for some length of time while you gain it off the other tank, or resets the other tank's threat for an amount of time.

In so many ways no.
How do you plan on getting hate from me for a tank swap mechanic when you'll be no where near my threat level? Do you plan on dragging down the overall damage by staying one step behind me in your tank stance and enmity combo?
Provoke may put you 1 point above the leader, but when the leader has 75% more aggro bar than you, it means a lot more than 1 point.

I'd hate to be in your group if that's the case, that you wont sacrifice a cross class ability for the key component for every tank to have because you're role playing yourself as some tank god?
Case in point, have your provoke button, god dammit!

[Kuwagami]

...

The question was about what content you tanked in FFXIV though. Because considering your joining date on the forums, you have witnessed a batload of fights needing those tank swaps, and needing provoke.

T1, T2, T5 needed provoke (though T5 has been solo tanked soon enough, but the initial concept was a tank swap). Garuda Ex, Titan Ex, Ifrit Ex, Ramuh Ex needed a tank swap. Shiva Ex had tank swaps encouraged but not actually needed per say.

T6 had tank swaps. T10, T11, T12 had tank swaps.

A1 and A3 needed provoke. A5,A7 and A8 encouraged it a lot. can't comment on the savage versions since I didn't enter them but I'd think the swaps were forced there.

Thordan required provoke too.

You can argue all you want, if you manage a tank swap without using provoke, either you or your tank mate is doing an horrible job. And it's not like a provoke is hard to do either. Provoke into halone, even off-combo, is usually enough to keep hate easily

[Bughuntlv426]

can't comment on the savage versions since I didn't enter them but I'd think the swaps were forced there.

A10s makes you provoke every 90 seconds or so lol, you can tank ult the hits but its desgined for OT to voke off MT and MT runs away. if boss mob follows MT bye bye MT. damage is based on proximity to boss