Irrespective of the nerf, the biggest problem here is that SCHs DPS in 4.0 makes a 2.0 era paladin like a Disgaea game in comparison.

The moment their co healer and the fairy can handle all of the HPS requirements is the moment SCH's gameplay becomes about as boring as imaginable.

Single target situation? 2 dots, oGCD, broil spam.

Aoe target situation? 2 dots, oGCD, broil spam.

I suspect a lot of the top progression SCHs aren't too thrilled with this, mine is already hinting that it's my turn to be the 'off healer' =(