Personal Loot

[Paladinleeds]

The person you quoted clearly doesn't know that you can choose loot specialization in WoW's personal loot system. There's no reason it wouldn't work here. Want monk gear? Go in as any job and choose monk as your loot specialization so you only get drops suitable to monk. They can even add an option of "all jobs" for those who can't decide.

I'm willing to accept everything but the bolded part. Add this and it'll have people select "all jobs" for the chance to roll need on every item and that becomes the only option used. I can compromise insofar as it picking a single job at random though.