Choosing a tank class..

[FallenWings]

I have always liked Warrior because of their damage capability but do not know where they stand now in that regard. Paladin is a bit boring and dark knight although very cool seems very convoluted. You really have to pay attention as a Warrior though. You can't just tank everything with your face.

I remember doing Turn 5 for the first time as a Warrior, I was MT. It was hard to stay alive if I did not use Inner Beast immediately following a Death Sentence.

I'd have to disagree. WAR is by far the easiest tank class, and even the easiest class to perform well with in the game. With it's short yet powerful cooldowns, you're hardly even punished as hard for blowing them early and if you needed a CD and all of your options were expended, you would just IB. The class is a 5 button wonder that gets the best results for the least amount of effort expended. (Hur dur Storm's Eye > BB > Fell Cleave on cooldown.)

PLD at the very least needs to put thought on when to use Goring and its OGCDs aswell as struggle against its own poor design(lul).

[Ayuris]

I'd have to disagree. WAR is by far the easiest tank class, and even the easiest class to perform well with in the game.

I'd have to disagree, simply because both WAR and DRK have something PLD does not - currency that can be spent either offensively or defensively.
While the toolkit of WAR is in no means harder to utilize than PLD, it's the management of Wrath stacks that make or break a good WAR.