Quote Originally Posted by Driavna View Post
... Yoshi is not happy with Omni's (needing to level all DoH scare people)...
I have friends which are ALC and CUL spec, entirely because they want to craft their own raid food / pots. Almost all other crafting and gathering makes them cringe.
As an OMNI, like many in this thread, I would not be the least bit upset if Specialist got the original intent; give them skills to compete with OMNIs.

My proposed solution:
Each specialisation would grant you 3 cross class skill from unlearned crafting classes. Great benefit for Specialist only, no benefit to OMNIs.
Remove good/excellent proc condition requirement from Byregot's Brow and Innovative Touch.

These changes would make 3 specialist crafters rotation equivalent to OMNIs without removing OMNIs advantage being able craft everything.
It does grant OMNIs the minor ability to not have to cross class Byrgot's Blessing and Innovation but those skills are actually stronger than the Specialist versions.
Byregot's Brow = 150% + 10%; max is 250%
Byregot's Blessing = 100% + 20%; max is 300%

Innovative Touch - 70% success (SH2 assumed)
Innovation - 100% success - reliability of a rotation is preferred.

I would keep the Specialist recipe lockout system as it currently exists. Unlocking the scrips to switch sole stones achieves the OMNIs desire to solo craft everything.