Quote Originally Posted by Settiesama View Post
I need cloth gear. Smn gear drops, no other Smn or Blm. 100% chance to get it with need, 25% chance to get with greed. Yeah, I'll take my 100%. If I wanted leather, I would go Nin or Mnk, see the point?

Sorry, but this system is fair as it is. Want the gear, play the job, simple solution. The biggest counterpoint, is that the system ain't broken, we shouldn't be fixing what ain't broke. YOU need to try to validate your points for a change, but all you are doing is repeating what has already been discussed pages back, and has already been shot down by logic.
It seems we will not be able to find an agreement in this matter. I am in support of this system because it would reserve the need button only for those that want that particular item, as opposed to those that only want it for its numeric value. The only other change it would have, is that whether or not you get a drop is determined when people are rolling, rather than when the drop is determined. I see this as the ideal use of the need/greed system. It is clear that most people do not share this view though, so I'll leave it here.