Anyone else thinks Proto Ultima is fine?

[Eve_Neuschwanstein]

Im kinda relieved its not a 24 man extreme fight. The 24 man content we have is already wipefest hellholes, because people still wipe at fights like Ozma, Forgal and Diabolos, and they are not even challenging in any way, its all just faceroll content. Just imagine trying to do extreme level mechanics in a 24 man party.... I wonder why people suck so much at 24 man content, maybe they just assume its fine to afk in there, seriously, i dont understand.

[RokkuEkkusu]

I'm impartial to it. I finally get to fight Proto-Ultima and rewards are cool. But the setting really doesn't fit much IMO.

As easy as the fight is in Dun Scaith, people wipe to Proto-Ultima for a few reasons:

1. Tanks fighting over aggro, getting others cleaved with Diffractive Laser
2. Really low dps

[SokiYagami]

I believe it was placed there to prevent the Proto-Ultima battle from falling into disuse like the Odin Trial did. They mentioned that being a problem before and that they had a plan to prevent it this time. Their plan appears to be inserting Proto-Ultima as an encounter in a Raid.

Just like many other content in the game, great idea, flawed execution.

[Misutoraru]

I have not encounter it yet
but I think one of the reason some ppl found it easy, and some ppl dont, are mainly the iL
I took break at 3.1, so when I first come back week ago, people are running around with iL270 while mind is 200
without sync they have superior gear, so when i do Void Ark with my 17X AST, i barely have 10k HP while everyone is running around 20K up
in that case most ppl just ignore mechanics, and i die because of that
the same issue apply in Wiping city of Mhach, other player running with 270, I m doing with my Void Ark set with barely 14k HP
and I found some bosses still a tough fight, not many mistake can be make
i have die in Arachne Eve because people dont care take orbs
i have die in Forgall because people dont care to take down adds or not enough people to stand in pillar
i have die in Ozma because someone mess up with meteor
and unlike those 270, Calofisteri hair cut is a death sentence for me
i do not found the Dun Scaith easy, it takes time to remember mechanics, it is not the hard part, but with my low HP pool, i have little room for mistake
it is 235iL 24ppl raid, so I can see if Proto ultima was put in this, the difficulty will be at 235iL

[Laerune]

A 2 minute fight.... I dont know part of me is happy it dies fast so the raid can be finished sooner, another part of me wish it was more like Odin.

[Shikiseki]

I mean I get that placing him into a 24man raid would make sense but... the execution is rather typical SE-like - very uncreative.

He could easily appear randomly throughout the entire dungeon (maybe only shoot random aoe lazers during bossfights) or randomly replace one of the trash pulls with him. Heck even a 50% chance of him appearing would have been fine with me. They mentioned Dun Scaith would have different kind of layout than the rest of the raids they could have risked something new but played it safe... as usual