Stop Giving the "Need" Command for Drop Gear in Dungeons to Higher Geared Players!

[Pintsized]

It's Usability-based. If you can equip it on your class, you can Need, if not you can only Greed. You want gear for a class, go into the dungeon on that class.

And what if you ARE on the same class?

Sorry, 'needing' on an item which is inferior to yours shouldn't be enabled, you don't NEED it you're by definition being GREEDy and games should do anything they can to mitigate player selfishness.

[Masekase_Hurricane]

And? You're still perfectly able to roll Need on those things; the person you quoted is just stating their opinion of you for doing so. They're not trying to argue that doing so is wrong, just that they like you less for it. It's a subjective viewpoint.

I personally also do not roll Need for items that are not an upgrade, but I don't sour grapes over people who do. I'd just rather give everyone a fair chance to use said items in the exact same way I would - GC seals, desynth, vendor gil - or possibly even get lucky and score an upgrade for an alt job.

Actually they are saying it's wrong and butt hurt about it. That is why the poster said "automatically removes them from commendation list". Also my reply wasn't an argument either it was a subjective viewpoint from the other side. So not actually sure what you were getting at quoting me.

But anyway, re: Needing for GC seals, wouldn't it be so much faster/easier to FATE grind for those? I mean, I don't know how much you can get out of higher end FATEs, or what the conversion rate is for higher gear sets. And I know FATE grinding is a bit mind numbing (although be honest, dungeons aren't often very exciting either). But seems like you could spend 20-30 minutes rolling FATEs, and get as much or more seals as you would from Needing gear. But I could be wrong I guess.
Desynth is still valid, I suppose.

That would take more time I personally wouldn't grind for seals I get them from something I am already doing. When I enter EX roulette/60 I am entering for Lore,Scrips,Desynth and Grand company seals. Once I have enough lore or scrips I wouldn't re-enter for grand company seals or Desynth.

Personally I would rather use my time to do multiple things at once. Same with Fates I would only do them if I wanted to work on another Anima but I would also do hunts, level my chocobo and level a class at the same time.

Although I would like to point out I don't lot on gear below 50 for seals, desynth etc. As I would rather pass to help novices and returning players.

[Blazinhart]

If you want seals so badly, why not try doing hunts or Fates for a change instead of simply taking gear away from people somebody else who might need it?

If you want gear for leveling so badly, why don't you craft or buy It for a change instead of simply complaining and thinking your need is superior to others?

[LunarEmerald]

Your needs don't outweigh the needs of others. Don't expect randoms to cater to you.

[Newmanxeno]

If they knew how to play said job, its unlikely they would be kicked.

I agree. If it's a dungeon from 1-49 there isn't much of a rotation to do. If it's 51-60 maybe I'd see them having a tough time.

[Fourbestintoner]

Dear, we don't owe you anything, you either need or pray.

[JunseiKei]

I am getting sick and tired of finding a piece of gear I need for one of my Job classes and someone with higher lvl gear who clearly doesn't need it anymore goes and hits the "Need" button anyways and snatches it away!

Higher levels geared players should NOT have the ability to do that and needs to be changed where they have to gamble with their luck through the Greed command like everyone else who's Job class doesn't relate to a certain piece of drop gear in a dungeon.

Did you try asking for said gear? Usually if a person asks ahead of time, people are nice enough to pass.

I know if dungeon gear drops on a class I'm playing, I'm rolling need. My need is always more ventures and doing F.A.T.E.s is inefficient in the sense that I'm only gaining seals and not lore/scripts and a chance at seals. Unless someone asks, I'll keep doing this, but will pass when asked.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

You get like, 200 seals per fate. Level 60 gear is worth over 1000 seals per piece.

[JunseiKei]

You get like, 200 seals per fate. Level 60 gear is worth over 1000 seals per piece.

And no lore/ scripts. I already explained this and it doesn't change the fact people can simply ask.

[ElHeggunte]

My first 6 months in this game, I would rip into anyone I saw need on something they didn't need, and many (subjectively) others agreed with me. Now, 3 years in, I've just given up. FFXIV players don't have the same outlook as people in other games when it comes to Need/Greed. Not sure why.

Because as others have already pointed out, there are more ways to use equipment outside of just wearing it. An item being a physical upgrade for you doesn't make it yours and doesn't make your need greater than the person who wants to use it for glamour or seals.

And what if you ARE on the same class?

Sorry, 'needing' on an item which is inferior to yours shouldn't be enabled, you don't NEED it you're by definition being GREEDy and games should do anything they can to mitigate player selfishness.

But who are you to tell them that they don't need it? Glamour, desynth, and seal exchange are a thing and are no less important than someone wanting to physically wear the equipment.