Community Feedback: Removing PvP Chat was wrong.

[itsoni]

Firstly, I understand why it was done. But this implementation shows it just doesn't work and in fact does more against the PVP community than anything for it.

Let us list why it doesn't work.

1) Doesn't remove the BM (Bad Manners/Toxicity) in chat. Players can still spam "Good Job!" for a whole 8 minute match. Yes, I've sat through it multiple times.

2) New players don't have a clue what they're supposed to do and nobody can tell them.

3) There's no way to say specific things or use custom macros even. How do I tell my team I'm out of MP? How do I tell the players not to pick up 8 stacks and run into the enemy? How do I tell them who I'm going to fullswing? How about something as simple as bursting a target at a specific time (e.g. B4B activation)?

4) This chat removal actually makes feeding etc easier. I've played a few matches already where players would run into the enemy base and /dance, while I'm watching the healers drain all their MP keeping him alive. He'll then afk at base while the whole team drop dead. There's no way to bring this to anyones attention.

That's only to highlight a few reasons. Also, why remove it in 4v4 Premade? What exactly does that accomplish? You're already playing with people you agreed to play with.

You know what I think? I think the reason this has been done is because they don't want to punish toxicity/wintraders in PvP. How many times have wintraders/feeders been reported? How many have actually had some sort of action on them? I think it was removed to "silence" the vocal PVP community who wanted players removed from the game for what they were doing.

Before you ask: I think they don't want to punish them just to keep them subbed. They want income. The team wants money and they don't want a vocal minority in the playerbase to become enough of a vocal majority, to force some action to be taken and remove a few subscriptions.

It's either that, or they want less work for the GM's... because the toxicity reason is invalid. It's still there, more than ever.

So where are the players who thought this was a good idea? You might enjoy it for the first 2 weeks, but when you're stuck at your skill level and can't progress, that's because there's nobody in your matches you can ask. When you come across one or two players in the enemy team that actually know how to press buttons, you won't understand what you're doing wrong. You'll become a burden to your team for the remaining 7 minutes.

Also, I'm looking for players who have actually done some Solo Queue Feast since the chat change. What is it actually like? I've got the mounts etc etc so I'm just waiting for Season 4 to roll around.

Feel free to leave your thoughts below. I hope they break their silence on this soon, I can see the JP playerbase is as frustrated as we are.

inb4 se remove "nice job!"

[KusoWat]

There is a giant thread on this already. Why not post your thoughts there?

[TiramisuMacaron]

There are actually 2 giant threads now. One got excommunicated from general chat.

[Pyrali]

At least this one has a nice list of reasons why in the first post instead of a vague complaint.

Adding to this, it removes a lot of room for specialized skills such as Sleep, Holmgang, Vuln+ skills, and other important cooldowns that people often macro'd.

There is no opportunity to teach, or to learn. I learned a lot by asking questions in the briefing period, because that's what the briefing period at the start was for.

If I left myself open to feedback and responded, people were generally really nice about it--because I was showing effort in learning and trying to help my team.

People who go in there with an I Can Do No Wrong Don't Question Me attitude were the ones getting yelled at, and quite frankly brought it on themselves. If you go in there and act like a belligerent, uncooperative twat, you're going to get called out.

By showing you have an interest in helping and succeeding, your team was way friendlier, imagine that! Nicer team, and you get to learn!

If you keep running in and making the same mistakes, frustration is bound to happen--just like it does in Trials and Primals! How about we remove party chat next?

But no, they cry! You can't remove Party Chat from Raids, Pyrali! How else will people learn?

Same shit in PvP my dude. No difference.

Nothing worse than any other area of the game has ever happened in PvP. Steps of Faith? Final Steps of Faith, Chrysalis, all the EX Primals... I could go on forever about all of the nasty shit I have seen said in there. But I won't, because it really does not fucking matter at the end of the day.

[TiramisuMacaron]

Should probably just keep all input in the longest post for the slight chance of it being noticed.

[Ama_Hamada]

1. There is more toxicity in DF chat then PvP, I would bet PvP is more often reported though, based on comments I seen in game.
2. I can't tell people to change jobs or point out we are fighting with 4 healers and 4 dps
3. tell someone to change to healer because 1 healer in 8 v 8 is unplayable unless the other side is clueless

I think it was done because GM staff is too small and can't really handle things as is. I say that because people think GMs are useless and don't take care of harassment. I think this happens because unless the ticket is worded in a specific way or the person is not persistent, it gets pushed aside easier.

People who go in there with an I Can Do No Wrong Don't Question Me attitude were the ones getting yelled at, and quite frankly brought it on themselves. If you go in there and act like a belligerent, uncooperative twat, you're going to get called out.

I agree, and I see that attitude more in DFs, that is why I am so shocked SE did this to pvp. Since Pvp is really weird in this game, I see people more willing to learn.
In the end having no chat does more harm then good, I am shocked SE did this, since you know, chatting in DF is still a thing and houses more toxicity when you try to offer advice on bosses, etc, or toxic fast pulling.

[KusoWat]

At least this one has a nice list of reasons why in the first post instead of a vague complaint.

Literally all of these points were already covered in the first thread.

[Llus]

More feedback on feast chat restriction/macros

I think this should be in bugs, why? Here:

Unable to let monk know to use fists of earth vs fists of fire.
Unable to tell black mage to sleep the opposing paladin.
Unable to tell the team to split damage when going against PLD + WHM combo.
Unable to tell healer that the enemy WAR likes to get off buff and will try to force you to attune early.
Unable to let team know to save burst until after the first LB box is up.
Unable to tell the bard that likes to grab all the medals to stop.
Unable to tell the tank to only grab 100 medals because they become squishier than a snail when they do.
Unable to tell DPS that ranged is bursting has B4B up and to burst immediately.
Unable to tell the team that mele is about to LB and needs backup to finish target off.
Unable to .... There are too many scenarios, too many play styles and too much information for simple messages to be effective.

[Yoruno]

There is a giant thread on this already. Why not post your thoughts there?

The previous thread was basically just a nonsensical whine with fancy language and brought up no valid points why we need chat.

There are actually 2 giant threads now. One got excommunicated from general chat.

This is a feedback thread, the threads posted before-hand were talking about the implications the system could possibly propose. You guys on the forums lol.

[KusoWat]

The previous thread was basically just a nonsensical whine with fancy language and brought up no valid points why we need chat.



This is a feedback thread, the threads posted before-hand were talking about the implications the system could possibly propose. You guys on the forums lol.

Except there is. A ton. Have you read it at all?