MSQ SPOILERS!!! Question

[Beckett]

I wouldn't be so sure of that not beeing the actuall Rhalgr.
The rule of creating something new out of their imagination only applies for beeings that where not primals before like Good KIng Moogle Mog and Shiva which were a living Moggle and Elezen in the past, for all we know the twelve are nothing different from Primals like Garuda and such (don't forget they are gods for the wild tribes) and as far as I know we do fight the actuall gods, at least as far as the game tells us.

What your point really boils down to is: Does Rhalgr exist? If Rhalgr (and the rest of the Twelve) actually exist, then the thing that is summoned is not Rhalgr, but a distorted approximation of him. if Rhalgr doesn't exist in some form, then this primal is the "real" Rhalgr because that's the only Rhalgr that will ever be in the world.

[Tam_Hawkins]

What your point really boils down to is: Does Rhalgr exist? If Rhalgr (and the rest of the Twelve) actually exist, then the thing that is summoned is not Rhalgr, but a distorted approximation of him. if Rhalgr doesn't exist in some form, then this primal is the "real" Rhalgr because that's the only Rhalgr that will ever be in the world.

More or less,
I should have said a bit more there I think.
If I understand the game and the lore right then Primals can be created, BUT when created once they will go back into the aether if destroyed and wait here for their next summon.
So what I meant is what if the Twelve always were Primals? They were summoned once, did their thing, walked back into the aether and the People remembered these powerfull beeings and started worshipping them and now Rhalgr gets resummoned?