Results -9 to 0 of 1541

Threaded View

  1. #11
    Player
    Shippuu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    628
    Character
    Shippuu Nammuu
    World
    Balmung
    Main Class
    Marauder Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by frankenbeans View Post
    So I went and checked his "proof".

    He can't even count correctly. He conveniently forgets to add FF8's Quistis Trepe making it 16. He doesn't Add blue mage from final fantasy explorers but yet does so on Samurai. Bringing Blue mage up to 17. There WAS NO SAMURAI in Final Fantasy 9 as Steiner was not a samurai but a Knight. -1 for samurai. If we are counting Bravely Defaults Sword master as Samurai then We count Vampire and Catmancer as Blue mage. Blue mage was in the game data of final fantasy record keeper but Ill be generous and leave it off.
    I merely mistyped FF8 as FF7 on the list, and I have Explorers on both lists. So a mistake on my end that doesn't change the total count, and a reading comprehension fail on your end that still doesn't change the count. And if we're counting BS like FFX-2's gun mage, despite not being called a blue mage, and not using something called blue magic, then Steiner from IX counts given his sword art mechanic functions almost identically to the recurring Samurai mechanic of Bushido, this is why I included him. But hey, I can take him off the list, and as ErikMynhier pointed out, I missed a samurai in the form of Parivir from Tactics A2, so it doesn't effect the total number of SAM.

    I didn't include Bravely Default since it's not technically a Final Fantasy game, and considering both SAM and BLU had representation in both games they would not have effected the numbers. This was doing you a favor because if we counted that, then we would have also needed to count Samurai Rising, of which would have given yet another point to the Samurai tally and not the Blue Mage one.
    You'll also note I have not edited my post, so the list is still there as I had initially typed it.

    So To repeat he left off FF8 and Final Fantasy Explorers from his Blue list. Making Total it a Total of 17.
    So to recap, I mis-typed FF8 as FF7, and taking away Steiner, but adding FFTA2 Parivir for Samurai, makes the total still: 15 for Blue Mage, 16 for Samurai.

    So there you go. I am willing to believe that it was just a simple counting error and was not intentional but there's your proof that Blue Mage made more appearances than Samurai.
    So you're still wrong, and Samurai has still appeared in more Final Fantasy games than Blue Mage.


    Edit: As pointed out as I'm reading the replies I missed while sleeping. I have overlooked the Enemy Skill materia from FF7, however, if we're going to count that, then Gil Toss is also a materia from 7 too, which is Samurai ability, so arguably FF7 should be on both lists, which still doesn't change the outcome.
    (2)
    Last edited by Shippuu; 01-23-2017 at 06:38 AM.