Steal FFXV's Fishing System

[MicahZerrshia]

As a fisher in this game...NO

It reminded me a lot of the fishing system in ffxi which was horrendous. I likely will be doing very little fishing in xv just like i did none in xi, because it's annoying

[Medicine]

I haven't played cute boi's in a car yet... I dunno how the fishing is.

But no the fishing in ffxiv is fine.

[Windseraph]

No thanks, fishing in FFXV is the sole reason I don't have a platinum trophy yet, it's horrid.

[SpookyGhost]

XV fishing actually feels like real fishing which is why people who play XIV will be put off by it. The XIV system is basically Animal Crossing's fishing system (a game mainly marketed toward children who have a lot of free time on their hands), except you can change bait in XIV.

All the DoH jobs remind me of this, basically: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7GAtSIy4-w

[Clethoria]

(a game mainly marketed toward children who have a lot of free time on their hands)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VeWC9V2qH-8

[Synestra]

XV fishing actually feels like real fishing which is why people who play XIV will be put off by it.

And this is why we need it here! it also looks alot like modern/slightly altered version of BoF3 fishing minigame where you need to reel and tap to get "tech" points so fish bites. Dunno but everytime there is fishing in a RPG i go nuts with it sadly XIV fishing is almost boring as it was in WoW, currently getting my fishing fixes in Stardew Valley.

[Clethoria]

And this is why we need it here! it also looks alot like modern/slightly altered version of BoF3 fishing minigame where you need to reel and tap to get "tech" points so fish bites. Dunno but everytime there is fishing in a RPG i go nuts with it sadly XIV fishing is almost boring as it was in WoW, currently getting my fishing fixes in Stardew Valley.

So would you also want fall damage to result in death instead of 1hp? It's just like real falling after all. Or how about perma death? Or ailments on the field for being too hot, cold or hunger status which can also result in death.

[DJMau]

I'd be up for the mini game idea

[Derio]

No. Way too much work and resources used. I can catch 5 or more fish in ffxiv than it takes to catch 1 fish in ffxv