Alternative dialogue collection?

[Vele]

Severian actually has 3 different dialogue in the event.

Haven't unlocked ALC at all:

What's this? Your face is unfamiliar to me--and I am not particularly inclined to waste my time in getting to know you--but whoever you are, it would appear that you're more competent at my erstwhile apprentice's job than he is. Heh heh heh. Mwahahahahaha!

Unlocked ALC:

Well, well--if it isn't that lackey of mine! I know not the details--and am not particularly inclined to waste my time in hearing them--but it would appear that you're more competent at my erstwhile apprentice's job than he is. Heh heh heh. Mwahahahahaha!

Have ALC at 50 (or 60?), I think this is the only cutscene he actually doubles in up laughter, but it's also possible I wasn't paying attention when I did this quest on my alts:

Well, well--if it isn't my able assistant! I must say, it's good to see that at least one person in this room hasn't let my esteemed tutelage go entirely to waste like my erstwhile apprentice here. Heh heh heh. Mwahahahahaha!

"Erstwhile" and "apprentice" don't look like real words anymore, and I don't know why I didn't copy/paste his laugh after the first time I typed it out, but there you go.

[Cilia]

You get the last possibility if you have ALC at 50, at least. (I haven't kept up with crafting classes in Heavensward because the barrier is steep from 2.0 - 3.0 if you didn't get deep into endgame crafting then... which I didn't because I just wanted the freedom to make my own glamour prisms for every class.)

[Yuella]

There are actually 3 dialogues when you meet Estinien in the MSQ:
- Haven't unlocked DRG: Estinien doesn't recognize you.
- Unlocked DRG but haven't sone the level 50 quest: Estinien recognizes you but says nothing else.
- Cleared DRG level 50 quest: Estinien calls you an Azure Dragoon.

[Cilia]

The gifts you get from the 2016 Starlight Celebration are one of three possibilities:

1. Allagan Bronze Piece x3 (300 gil)
2. Allagan Silver Piece (500 gil)
3. Clear Demimateria I x2

[Rocl]

Eh? I guess if you wanted all the possible interactions for Starlight I can save you the trouble (you missed the cutest part of Alphinaud's visit!):

Of fun and games at the Gold Saucer.
Godbert:

Ho ho ho! I say, it is good to see you again, my friend─ah, we have met before, have we not? It is I, the wandering pilgrim known far and wide for gifting gifts to assiduous adventurers such as yourself!
In truth, I had a mind to wield my hammer of legend and forge for you a masterwork of goldsmithery worthy of your efforts, but I fear that my attention was required...elsewhere. But worry not, for I have procured a present which should more than suffice as a substitute!
Ah, but it would seem dawn is nigh, and so I must return and do what only a Man─ah, a wandering pilgrim-man can. Until we meet again...and do remember to look under the tree!

Of beasts wondrous and rare.

Creepy paissa in a Dream cap.

Of your adventures in Limsa Lominsa.
Y'shtola:

'Twould seem you have done some good this year. And so I come, bearing a gift from the Spinner. Do not ask why She chose me─surely this gaudy frock would better suit Yda, or Tataru...
Still, it calls to mind one Starlight many summers ago, when I awoke to find a small ribbon beside my pillow. Master Matoya took me to task when I suggested she was the one who had placed it there. Still, I knew the truth, and was rather moved by the gesture.
...But l have dwelt on the past long enough.
The dawn comes, and I am summoned elsewhere. Be well, friend─and do not neglect to look beneath the tree when you awaken.

Of your adventures in Gridania.
Yda & Papalymo:

Papalymo: Ah, [name]. Fancy meeting you here. I trust you have been a good adventurer this year?
Yda: [S/he] sure has! That's why I brought gifts! Well, a gift, at least. I'm sorry, Papalymo─I forgot to bring something for you!
Papalymo: Well, then it is fortunate I am not a child, isn't it? If anything, it is I who should be gifting little trinkets to you...not that I have the slightest intention of doing so.
Yda: O-Of course, silly me! Sometimes I forget that you're so much older than me! Was it forty summers now? Fifty?
Papalymo: Do you see the sun coming up on the horizon, Yda? That's our cue to leave...now.
Yda: Awww, and just when I was starting to have fun! Well, see you around, [name]! And don't forget to peek under the tree when you wake up!

Of your adventures in Ul'dah.
Thancred:

Ah, [name]. Sleeping like a babe, I see. Why the puzzled look? 'Tis I, the saint's little helper. Mayhap you were expecting another?
Curious, is it not? Not once did I have occasion to celebrate Starlight as a child, but now, as a man grown, I celebrate it with you─at least, in a manner of speaking.
Ah, but dawn is nigh, and I must bid you a fond farewell. May your dreams be sweet, and do remember to peek under the tree when you awake. Till we meet again!

Of great nations and those who lead them.
Nanamo:

Hail, adventurer! By the grace of the Spinner, I, Nanamo Ul Namo, seventeenth of my line, do hereby confer upon you a gift for your most beneficent deeds this Starlight season!
I am reminded of our own festivities at the palace, in the days when Father and Mother yet lived. The sumptuous feasts, the beatific choirs, the majestic tree that stretched up to the ceiling─would that I could take you there to see it all!
Yet alas, dawn breaks...and our time together must draw to a close. Now rise, my champion, and claim your prize!

Of the menace of an empire.
Alphinaud:

Well met, [name]! I come bearing a gift from the Spinner Herself as guerdon for your most charitable deeds. That said, just between the two of us, this coat is a tad garish for my liking...
How ironic that Nymeia should choose me of all people to do Her bidding. I was a skeptical child, as you might imagine, and quick to doubt the stories of the saint. Grandfather would spare no effort in concocting elaborate tales to preserve the illusion─yet I would not yield in my pursuit of the truth. Oh, the battles of wit we had!
While I would like nothing more than to stay and reminisce, I fear I must depart with the dawn. I shall leave your present beneath the tree. Till we next meet, friend!

Of primals and beastmen.
Tataru:

A happy Starlight to you, <name>. I come bearing a gift and a song, especially for you! Just a moment... Ahem! Trololololo～lololo～♪
On this most high and holy night,♪
The snow without lies crisp and white...♪
But love burns hot within my heart,♪
I pray that we shall never─♪
Oh dear, is that the hour? I'll just have to sing the rest for you another time! Now, what have I forgotten? ...Oh, yes─your present! I'll just leave it under the tree, shall I? Till we meet again!

Of the Dragonsong War.
Aymeric:

I trust this Starlight season finds you well, my friend? I, Aymeric de Borel, lord commander of the Temple Knights of Ishgard, have come to bestow upon you a most special gift.
As you well know, the observance of Starlight traces its origins to my homeland, where it remains a much-beloved tradition to this day.
I have always been quite fond of the season myself. Though I must confess that as colors go, I am somewhat partial to blue...
Nonetheless, it is both an honor and a pleasure to celebrate this Starlight with you. So as not to disturb your slumber, I shall leave your gift beneath the tree. Be well, my friend.

C'MON ALPHINAUD AND LOUISOIX BEING SO CUTE PLS

I also found it adorable the gifts I've gotten so far were such pittances, since y'know, they're from kids.

[Cilia]

Way to steal my thunder... >_>

Ah well, I'll keep updating the gift listing at least.

[TinyRedLeaf]

Eh? I guess if you wanted all the possible interactions for Starlight I can save you the trouble (you missed the cutest part of Alphinaud's visit!):

Of your adventures in Limsa Lominsa.
Y'shtola: 'Twould seem you have done some good this year. And so I come, bearing a gift from the Spinner. Do not ask why She chose me─surely this gaudy frock would better suit Yda, or Tataru... Still, it calls to mind one Starlight many summers ago, when I awoke to find a small ribbon beside my pillow. Master Matoya took me to task when I suggested she was the one who had placed it there. Still, I knew the truth, and was rather moved by the gesture... But l have dwelt on the past long enough. The dawn comes, and I am summoned elsewhere. Be well, friend─and do not neglect to look beneath the tree when you awaken.

By the way, when it comes to your adventures in Limsa Lominsa, the version of Y'shtola who appears in your dreams will depend on whether your character has reached Heavensward yet.

If yours is a pre-Heavensward character, it will be the Ver2.0 Y'shtola who visits. If your character has already begun Heavensward and got past the point where you save Y'shtola from the Lifestream, you'll see Ver3.0 Y'shtola instead.

In both cases, though, she has the same dialogue. There's still some time left, for those of you who want to confirm this.

[Rocl]

If I had to guess the same is true of adventures in Ul'dah and Thancred as well!

[Fenral]

I will admit, I had a mild heart attack when I saw a post of G'raha Tia appearing in one of those dream sequences. It was just a really well-done tribute, alas, not the kind of foreshadowing we got with Haurchefant a couple years back.