Quote Originally Posted by Talraen View Post
Question for anyone who favors RNG-only dungeon drops: would you also favor random experience gains? Like, instead of gaining experience for each kill based on the level of the mob, you randomly gain experience each time you do anything, at a very low rate. Essentially, using FFXI's skillup system for experience. Where you can do a leve and maybe you'd gain a full level, or maybe you'd gain absolutely nothing. Does that sound appealing?

Because that's the same concept as RNG-only drops. It's also the original class experience system in 1.0. A system that was so hated that it was changed almost immediately. A system that caused almost all of my friends to quit even before they realized all of the other myriad flaws in 1.0. So... why are we calling for that kind of system, again?
No, I would not like that, and I don't see it as a remotely similar concept.