Thread: Request: Ability to re-assign class levels after 1.20

Originally Posted by Duuude007

The original design for THM was clear in the job description, (i.e. master of destruction, moreso than even the disciples of War). It just wasnt implemented as intended, (it was overpowered as healer & in survivability) and took a long time to be fully rebalanced, due to other, higher priority fixes. Guess what? It is now almost fully rebalanced to reflect that original job decription.

Given that shortly after release, Sacrifice was specifically buffed to heal more on the initial cast, it would seem that the original vision for THM (as a healer) is what existed prior to 1.18.

Originally Posted by Spider-Dan

Given that shortly after release, Sacrifice was specifically buffed to heal more on the initial cast, it would seem that the original vision for THM (as a healer) is what existed prior to 1.18.

The original job description said that it's a destructive class. How does a slight buff to healing potency all of a sudden make it a class specifically designed for healing?

Originally Posted by Spider-Dan

So then, when you saw CNJ's spell list of full elemental nuke lines (along with ancient magic nukes), you thought it was clear that CNJ absolutely would not be BLM?

It wasn't obvious either way. Both classes had aspects of different traditional FF jobs. CNJ could have been BLM just as easily as they were made WHM.

Everyone's assessment of CNJ at the beginning was that it was a mix of both WHM and BLM since it had the trademark skills from both.

The general assessment of THM was that it was something akin to a magic-heavy RDM due to the debuffs.

The point the above poster is making is that it was obvious that CNJ had the most spells related to healing and defense, much more than THM.

CNJ: cure, stoneskin, protect, shell, shockspikes, paralyna, silena, poisona

THM: sacrifice, stygian spikes

The vast majority of THM's spells are for debuffing/nuking. CNJ had more healing/buffing spells from the start.

Originally Posted by Spider-Dan

Given that shortly after release, Sacrifice was specifically buffed to heal more on the initial cast, it would seem that the original vision for THM (as a healer) is what existed prior to 1.18.

Given that shortly after release, Scourge, Banish, and Absorb spells were specifically buffed to deal more damage when cast, it would seem that the original vision for THM (as a damage dealer) is what existed prior to 1.18.

Either both are true or neither is true. Nice try.

Originally Posted by Duuude007

Either both are true or neither is true.

...or, THM was envisioned as a hybrid, just like CNJ was.

Originally Posted by Spider-Dan

...or, THM was envisioned as a hybrid, just like CNJ was.

Thaumaturge (THM)
In the hands of a skilled practitioner, thaumaturgy can be a force of terrifying destruction. At the heart of this school of magic lies the ability to call forth and command the latent aether within oneself through deep introspection.
To mold that aether into sorcery, the thaumaturge makes use of a scepter or staff, within which is housed a medium - a natural stone imbued with magical properties. The guild is centered at the Arrzaneth Ossuary in Ul'dah, within whose hallowed walls are said to reside powers of life, death, and the beyond.

Thaumaturges are unparalleled in their powers of destruction, eclipsing even the Disciples of War.

By enfeebling enemies and enhancing their allies, thaumaturgy can prove to be an invaluable asset, particularly in battles of attrition.

versus

Conjurer (CNJ)
Conjury calls upon elemental forces present in nature and concentrates them to a potency at which spells can be weaved. Through practiced meditation on the essences of creation, conjurers draw forth and absorb aether from their immediate surroundings. A wand or cane made from unworked wood is then utilized to focus the aether until it manifests as the desired spell. The seat of the Conjurers' Guild lies at the Stillglade Fane in Gridania, where the voices of Eorzea's elementals are said to be the most powerful.
Conjurers are trained to coax metaphysical forces forth from the elements which comprise all of creation, allowing them to weave powerful spells.

Attuned to the essence of all things around them, the conjurers' intimacy with all forms of being enables them to shift between both offensive and defensive magic as needed.

See the distinction? We certainly do.

Based on the native MP management abilities THM is scheduled to receive, it is unlikely that THM will be able to support an MP pool as a cross-class healer.

Originally Posted by Spider-Dan

Based on the native MP management abilities THM is scheduled to receive, it is unlikely that THM will be able to support an MP pool as a cross-class healer.

If this is your only concern, I am at a loss. Too bad there is no such thing as:

THM having the largest MP pool among all the classes, boosted further when BLM.
Native mp regen
Ethers
THM Abl. 5 (aka the new spirit song)
BLM Abl. 1 (aka convert)
THM Mag. 2 (aka the new stygian spikes)

...but wait, all of these are true.

What do you have to complain about? You can continue to be a mediocre healer, but with a massive MP pool at your disposal.

Back to our summary statement: Quit trying to fix something that's not broken.

Originally Posted by Duuude007

If this is your only concern, I am at a loss. Too bad there is no such thing as:

THM having the largest MP pool among all the classes, boosted further when BLM.
Native mp regen
Ethers
THM Abl. 5 (aka the new spirit song)
BLM Abl. 1 (aka convert)
THM Mag. 2 (aka the new stygian spikes)

In order:

- MP pool doesn't mean much when you have no effective way to refill it
- every class has native MP regen
- every class can use ethers (and that is no more a serious solution than potions)
- THM Abl. 5 is for attack magic only
- you have no way to know that BLM will even be able to equip cross-class abilities
- Stygian Spikes does nothing for MP regeneration if you aren't being hit

But I will say this: I didn't consider simply abandoning THM for BLM. If jobs are not class locked in the abilities they can use, that's a perfectly reasonable solution for my ends.

Much of THM's storyline revolves around the ability to resurrect... a healing ability.

At the end of the day, if you're trying to prove that THM was never meant to heal, they wouldn't have been giving a healing spell, and then had that healing spell buffed. The best you can argue is that CNJ was supposed to be a better healer, which does not mean that THM should not heal any more than the existence of WHM means that RDM should not heal.

It's fine to say that THM is not going to be able to heal in the future without trying to rewrite history. This game was intended to have two healing classes at release.