So I just got Shield Oath for the first time (finally Paladin is playable!) and decided to try a few things with it in my first run with it, I ended up in Cutter's Cry.

Playing a bit with the stances I realized I could get some advantage in aggro with the Shield Oath and after I had enough enmity in I could just swap to Sword Oath and get that extra dps in with absolute safety.

Well, it ends up that in the last boss, in the Chimera, the Monk complained about the stance swapping with a "Please stay in shield" while taking all AoEs in the face and not even being able to do his job, while I tanked it flawlesly in Sword Oath (after I got some enmity with Shield in). I'll be honest, I don't remember seeing Paladins doing what I did in -50 dungeons, but is it wrong to do that now?