Sadly I wasted my weekly on this as well. Did all my challenge logs, got the 9/9 stickers. Wanted to reshuffle to only find out I couldn't.

Totally my fault afterall that's what I get for assuming things before hitting reshuffle. I was rather ticked off.
Would of been nice if the quest npc had a more in depth explanation or even a little 'guide' on how those 2 options work.