During my time in FF14, I have had quite a few occasions where I'm conflicted as to who to give that 1 commendation too, like in my last df roulette, I had a Sch dpsing, Ninja goading other pcs also providing shadewalker on boss pulls and the Bard doing foes for the ninja and sch. To say it was quite a fast run is understatement, long story short, I was conflicted as to who to give the commendation too, I gave it to the sch in the end.

As a tank, I get a commendation for most of the dfs I'm in, as a healer some of the time and as a dps infrequently. Under normal circumstances my preference for who deserves a commendation is as follows, I priorities any new pcs, then healer/tank then the dps. I find it interesting, how there is a dichotomy when it comes to commendations depending on the role played at the time.

So my question is, do you have a preference as to who to give that 1 commendation out to, and have you ever been in a dilemma as to who to give it too?