About Tank Design Winner

[LadyVal]

How this 180 on the Allagan Luminous Surcoat happened, baffles me, which is why I am asking... have you created anything better? Has it been judged and won the competition? No? Didn't think so.

You obviously don't work in fashion or any other field where you regularly, publicly display your work. If you saw any of the mannequins I've ever dressed in my career, or outfits I picked for others, you would have an opinion about them, whether you could create better looks or not. Everyone does. That's how people work. You don't need to make the salary I do to judge my work when you see it just like nobody here needs to be able to design a "better tank armor" to judge the winning look when they see it.

[ErryK]

You obviously don't work in fashion or any other field where you regularly, publicly display your work. If you saw any of the mannequins I've ever dressed in my career, or outfits I picked for others, you would have an opinion about them, whether you could create better looks or not. Everyone does. That's how people work. You don't need to make the salary I do to judge my work when you see it just like nobody here needs to be able to design a "better tank armor" to judge the winning look when they see it.

That was an issue I had because the person in question thought they knew better than the judging group, so for the fact that they thought better, I wanted to know if they had anything better. You can have an opinion, but when an opinion has no backbone, I cannot take that as valid criticism or judgement of a design. It's preposterous to just take a glance, then just say it's boring, and end it at that.

[Colino]

I really wanted the Goobue armour to win, oh well.

[Elleia]

I really wanted the Goobue armour to win, oh well.

I think the goobbue armor will (or should) end up being implemented as an outfit that everyone can wear, ala the pig costume from the Gold Saucer. I think it would make more sense to do something like this rather than restrict it to tanking classes only.

[Brady672]

The set that was my favorite won

You know, besides the Goobue set.

[Teraluna]

This armour removes all your skills - because you don't need them. All you do is stand there and say "and that was your Ultimate? Thought you where just tickling me"

[Nuna]

This armour removes all your skills - because you don't need them. All you do is stand there and say "and that was your Ultimate? Thought you where just tickling me"

Looks like Iron Tarkus upgraded his armor.

[Mugiawara]

Ccorris and Gungira had the best one to me. that's literally a recolout of iron works. it's nicely drawn and all....but not original. very disappointed.

[Lisotte]

Oh yay, more butt-capes.

[Khalithar]

Oh yay, more butt-capes.

Anything but more of those. >_<