Petition to keep non-instanced dungeons.

[Tempestmoon]

Which is fine. But as they keep adding instanced dungeons some will be non-instanced. As he said "Many" not all. There will be plenty of open world content to explore as well.

Idealy I would like to see a mash of both for dungeons with an open non-instanced part and an instanced part. For example the first 2-3 floors could be open while the final stages and boss can be instanced. Another form of instance is to have it set up like guild leve's where you have your own sets of mobs for the culling. You would see others just like in the open field but other then that you would be on your own. I think in ways this would be a better. They have shown that they can keep things specific to the group such as mobs, doors, traps, keys. Hell they did it in XI as well. If there is any compromise to be had. I think it would be in such an option.

[Kiote]

Which is fine. But as they keep adding instanced dungeons some will be non-instanced. As he said "Many" not all. There will be plenty of open world content to explore as well.

Go read the 2.0 information again. It's says and I quote "All Non-Instanced Dungeons" will be converted into Instanced Dungeons.

[Kiote]

Having Open world HNMs and Massive PvE battles does not make up for the elimination of all Freely explorable zones. Having a series of instanced content that has enterence requirements is all well and good. Sometime, if done right(i.e. Nyzul Island) it can be very fun and challenging. But the simple fact remains that Instanced content becomes stale significantly faster than open world content. Open world dungeons allow for Community created fun on top of a significantly larger opportunity for developer made content. You can have a larger variety of content in an open world dungeon, as opposed to the Speed Run/Boss Battle content you get from instances.

When you remove things like timers you gain free exploration and the ability to really take in the zone. When is the last time you actually took a look around Toto-Rak or Darkhold? Probably never.

When you remove maximum group requirements you are no longer forced to tell friends they cannot join because there is no room. People say this makes Boss Battles less challenging because you can just throw bodies at it. I say, it opens bosses up to becomes Significantly more challenging with godly levels of strength that require massive parties. On top of that, for more standard bosses, you gain the ability to low man battles which requires significant skill and grants bragging rights to those who can complete major challenges with minimal assistance.

Finally, with open world dungeons you gain the ability to meet people in the field. MMOs are supposed to have a community. Players are supposed to happen across one another. when you remove that aspect from the game you minimize the ability of the community to grow and develop friends and rivals. Worse yet, you end up with a game in which players actually have to go online and apply for Friends on some LS's website. Yes, this allows people to weed out obnoxious player, but what you lose is the chance to happen upon a friendship with the thousands of players in the games world.

[HoolieWho]

Having Open world HNMs and Massive PvE battles does not make up for the elimination of all Freely explorable zones. Having a series of instanced content that has enterence requirements is all well and good. Sometime, if done right(i.e. Nyzul Island) it can be very fun and challenging. But the simple fact remains that Instanced content becomes stale significantly faster than open world content. Open world dungeons allow for Community created fun on top of a significantly larger opportunity for developer made content. You can have a larger variety of content in an open world dungeon, as opposed to the Speed Run/Boss Battle content you get from instances.

I don't know where you are getting the impression that there will be no freely explorable zones.

I disagree that instanced content becomes stale faster than open world content. I don't see that instancing has much to do with the longevity and replayability of content.

I disagree that you have a larger variety of content in an open world area versus a similarly sized instance. Again, whether an area is instanced or not doesn't have much bearing on what content you can put in.

When you remove things like timers you gain free exploration and the ability to really take in the zone. When is the last time you actually took a look around Toto-Rak or Darkhold? Probably never.

You can be against harsh time limits, but they are not a requirement of instancing. I doubt many people would go sight-seeing in Toto-Rak or the Darkhold if they had the opportunity. How many people do you find sight-seeing in the open world areas we have now?

When you remove maximum group requirements you are no longer forced to tell friends they cannot join because there is no room. People say this makes Boss Battles less challenging because you can just throw bodies at it. I say, it opens bosses up to becomes Significantly more challenging with godly levels of strength that require massive parties. On top of that, for more standard bosses, you gain the ability to low man battles which requires significant skill and grants bragging rights to those who can complete major challenges with minimal assistance.

Maximum group size is an important tool for balancing the difficulty of an encounter. I think it is a tragedy to see challenging encounters turned into zergfests. But there is content like the beastmen strongholds for variable sized groups to tackle.

Finally, with open world dungeons you gain the ability to meet people in the field. MMOs are supposed to have a community. Players are supposed to happen across one another. when you remove that aspect from the game you minimize the ability of the community to grow and develop friends and rivals. Worse yet, you end up with a game in which players actually have to go online and apply for Friends on some LS's website. Yes, this allows people to weed out obnoxious player, but what you lose is the chance to happen upon a friendship with the thousands of players in the games world.

I agree that it is important to meet people in an MMO. I think the best way is to have tools available to form groups to tackle the available content, instanced or otherwise. The lack of such tools in FFXIV is the game's greatest failing in my opinion. Content along the lines of behest and FFXI's Campaign and Besieged would be a nice addition to FFXIV. Aside from events like this, I'm not sure where you hope to roam and meet up with someone, except in the cities. It's certainly possible to form a pickup party at the gates of one of the beastmen strongholds, but I doubt that happens with any significant frequency in actual practice.

[Jynx]

If there is any compromise to be had. I think it would be in such an option.

Personally I thought it was the perfect system, I have no qualms with boss battles and certain NM's being instanced. Places like Seasearpent grotto were great (Although they lacked a instanced area at the end) the BCNM areas are perfect as well going through the beastmen fort to fight the beastmen forces at the end (Instanced) even if the BCNM is a far higher level than the area it's placed it gives the developers a area to develope the content around.