Is there anyway to rate a player I.E bad commendation i guess?

[Urthdigger]

I really wish we could name and shame players who play terribly. Maybe then people would give two shits about their party members.

[Kallera]

I really wish we could name and shame players who play terribly. Maybe then people would give two shits about their party members.

Good luck trusting a learning party with strangers. all it takes is one death that is your doing or an argument spinning out of control.

[Archaell]

Good luck trusting a learning party with strangers. all it takes is one death that is your doing or an argument spinning out of control.

The only learning parties you can trust are the "learning from the phase 1" ones - anything beyond that is filled with players performing bellow required standard. It's hopeless and there aren't any tools to fix the trust issues when these are justified.

The community driven "justice" system might be flawed, but it at least seems like you have a chance to decrease the amount of uncooperative behavior - being it active or passive toxicity.

I've heard rumors of JP players having a website or two that have server "blacklists" after enough evidence is collected against a player. Just curious, any truth to that?

I wonder if the blacklists have something to do with their better savage clear rates...

[NovaLevossida]

The community driven "justice" system might be flawed, but it at least seems like you have a chance to decrease the amount of uncooperative behavior - being it active or passive toxicity.

I don't really believe this. Twitter and mob justice has shown otherwise where group think becomes group attack. Social media has really shown that people will only abuse that power, and people are already too quick to jump to accusations and personal attacks. They do this all very visibly and publicly while encouraging others to join in on the fun. Reddit's FFXIV forum can't even use the downvote button in the correct manner. I wouldn't give those people the ability to publicly name players if they can't handle an arrow mechanic properly.