[REQUEST] Making MB selling fairer (in some way)

[Cakekizyy]

There is nothing broken about a free market.

[Kosmos992k]

The market board is fine, the TC just doesn't like the free market rules of supply and demand. Anything you do to prop up prices will inflate the game economy and we'll back to square one within weeks.

[Genaxx]

Its great the way it is because prices usually get refreshed every patch, I bet a loadof the GC seal items are going cheap at the moment due to all the fates, buy it up and sell it next patch.

If undercutting is an issue for you, put less gil into what your selling so you have a huge profit margin and you may be willing to go lower than others.

[Dzian]

One of the reasons people undercut is market flooding. When the same retainer lists 10 stacks of something highly profitable but only sells once every couple of days it seems quite obvious that the next person to come along Is going to list all there stacks at a lower price than those 10. Then you end up with 20 stacks of something that sells once every 2 or 3 days. Gonna take months for them all to be sold. And this is what drives down prices.

I use the history a lot when listing my stuff. Especially with material. Some of those can sell 15 or 20 times a day so I will usually put mine at the higher end of the market. There's days where I've sold a piece of material for 100k more than a friend who sold his only an hour earlier.

When it comes to crafting I tend to make several different things with decent profit rather than 10 of 1 thing that sells for a huge profit. As a result I don't get much trouble from undercutters

The only change to the market system I'd like to see is something that was in 1.23. The ability to specify quantity of goods. When I need 6 dhalmel leathers for example and the smallest stack on the market boards is 50. In 1.23 players had ano option to sell part stacks when they listed. So a guy like me could buy 6 items from that stack of 50.

The way it is now. Discourages selling a lot of the time. As people who would buy something just go to gather or farm it instead because they can't buy the amount they need without having tons of excess. Which reduces the circulation of money.

[MaeIsMean]

The only change to the market system I'd like to see is something that was in 1.23. The ability to specify quantity of goods. When I need 6 dhalmel leathers for example and the smallest stack on the market boards is 50. In 1.23 players had ano option to sell part stacks when they listed. So a guy like me could buy 6 items from that stack of 50.

This is a huge thing. I can't stand when I look up an item, and all I can find are stacks of 99, and I need like 3. I don't want to buy 99 at 1k each (or more), but I'd happily buy 4 or 5 instead. I always list mine in stacks of 5-25.

[MilesSaintboroguh]

This is a huge thing. I can't stand when I look up an item, and all I can find are stacks of 99, and I need like 3. I don't want to buy 99 at 1k each (or more), but I'd happily buy 4 or 5 instead. I always list mine in stacks of 5-25.

Ditto, and most of the time, the people selling in stupid high stacks are usually the ones trying to hold a monopoly so that you can't get it at a lower quantity.

[Lexia]

Yea I like XI's AH system better.

[CUTS3R]

Ditto, and most of the time, the people selling in stupid high stacks are usually the ones trying to hold a monopoly so that you can't get it at a lower quantity.

Until i arrive.

[Hasrat]

Never really understood the point of undercutting, myself. Surely just hurts their own profits in the long run.

Personally, I think the worst are those that list items at (or, strangely, below) NPC buy-back prices.

[WinterLuna]

Anyone is free to set whatever price they want. Undercutting isn't a 'problem', it's just frustrating. Players aren't doing anything wrong by selling their item for 1 gil less than someone else. The cost is lower, so of course someone is going to pay the cheapest price. It's up to you to monitor your own sales and set your own prices.