In order for Noct sect to be viable as an offhealer akin to (but different than) scholar, it would need to be the higher dps stance. as it is now, diurnal sect is higher dps because its benefit (speed) applies to all spells, while Noct's benefit (potency) applies to heals only. This needs to change, first and foremost. While all three healers have comparable dps, what lets scholars shine in the position of offheal dps, is the sheer amount of mp they have to work with. So, if SE doesn't want to buff Noct sect dmg, they could maybe reduce mp costs for offensive spells, or improve mp regen in noct sec, or something to help them fill the shoes of a scholar.

Scholar... well, sch is what I play, and I enjoy being overpowered. Overall, sch is really strong, but has a pretty high skill and knowledge cap. if you don't know the fight, its impossible to play sch to its optimal potential. The only real suggestion I have here would be to make Selene a little more appealing. if her silence were more reliable, and responsive whether or not her embrace is on cooldown, and if it had a cooldown comparable to other silences in the game, i'd be much more inclined to use her. It would also be nice if selene's ai would only use caress (her dispel) when there is actually something she could remove, instead of trying to use it on any debuff. While I'm not a fan of using sic, it would be nice if it wasn't quite so braindead.