The rewards would need to be designed so that it doesn't draw people away from those outdated content that the Anima weapon quests try to send people to.
  • Luminous Crystals try to populate leveling FATEs.
  • Unidentified materials populate roulettes (Eso/Poetics), hunts, and Alexander.
  • HQ Crafted are an important source of crafter income.
  • Aether Oils send people into Crystal Tower and roulettes (Eso).
While I will benefit a lot from having an extra source of those relic materials, I think the Aether Oil is the only good candidate. Maybe the unidentified mats, at a reasonable exchange rate.

I would welcome a raid roulette though. Definitely.