Would you like an in-game parser?

[Kaurie]

It's interesting. In this discussion there is more agreement than disagreement - which seems to be the case most often. The above is the reason why I have no problem with the possibility of a personal parser that remains private. I can see an argument for those being training aids, and you could work with friends and compare results while learning/training on a job.

A personal parser doesn't help either issue though. You won't know your DPS is good/bad if you have 0 idea what other people are doing. You go into expert and do 1500 DPS, grrrreeeaaat! I rock! Activate group parser and see the tank did 1200 and the other DPS did 2400.
Astrologians won't be able to plan their party buffs on the higher DPS if they cannot see the groups DPS.

I understand your point that many who are not pulling their weight at all might be oblivious to that. But you and I both know that we do not need a parser to see when another player is playing severely below normal ability. The question is whether having numbers to back up that judgement helps the situation. I don't think it does because your judgement is the same, you would just have numbers for 'proof' if required. But depending on your approach and the sensitivity of the other player your message can be welcomed or ignored, or even treated as provocation. Having the numbers wouldn't change that.

That depends what you mean. I have seen lots of players that on the surface look like they are fine, but the mobs are dying incredibly slow and we see 2-3 extra mechanics that you normally skip. If you mean they are constantly dying, I can see that. I can't see if some job I don't even have at 60 is doing their rotation wrong.

I went to Bismark EX the other day with a couple of friends in raid finder. For fun, I LB'd the adds before the last jump on the back, figuring we are 100 ilvls above the content - we can 1 shot the back. We did not 1 shot the back and the melee DPS fell to his death and then raged at me for using the LB. I told them I figured we'd have the DPS to 1 shot. He started crying about how he didn't realize it was a newb party, and that I obviously am an idiot for using the LB which was obviously required. I told him maybe if his DPS was higher, then we wouldn't have needed it. He said, "I know my DPS, my DPS is fine". My friend posted up the log, it was IIRC around ~1800 DPS for me, 1000, 800 and 300 for the other 3 DPS. The 300 was the guy raging (not exaggerated numbers, but it's been a few weeks, I may be off by a small margin). This guy obviously thought he knew what he was doing, but obviously didn't. A group parser would have shown him prior to creating confrontation for no reason.

I should add, I had 0 idea that the guys DPS was going to be that low based off the fight itself.

I think we agree on many of the individual issues, but perhaps on this one specific point we still disagree? Either way, let me ask you, if there was a personal parser built into the game as a training aid, but the numbers were private unless you share them in chat or something, would that not help in the way that most people argue a parser will help?

I think a personal parser has some advantages and some disadvantages. I also think that a personal parser would create more aggression than a group parser. Having everything in the open means that people can see what is up without having confrontation. If a DPS check is failed with personal logs, everyone has to report their numbers and people may lie or whatever. It just opens up another can of worms. As said earlier, a personal parser would also be unhelpful for buffs, and for determining how your DPS compares in 'ordinary' content.

[RobbieH]

Astrologians won't be able to plan their party buffs on the higher DPS if they cannot see the groups DPS.

Not entirely true, the Hate meter is a "hint" at who's doing more DPS, exception for openers (a bad DPS probably doesn't do a good opener to begin with) and if Quelling Strikes is used, even then if the hate bar on the other DPS is too small (exception for Monk due to being somewhat slow starters) don't use on them, or simply wait a bit before buffing people.

One thing is to check the gear, Raid Gear and/or Sophia weapon should indicate good players, still this doesn't mean they aren't bad, might be someone who got A12S weapon for a Job he doesn't play and is giving it a try.

In the end yes, for Astro is kinda hit and miss without parser.

[Kaurie]

Not entirely true, the Hate meter is a "hint" at who's doing more DPS, exception for openers (a bad DPS probably doesn't do a good opener to begin with) and if Quelling Strikes is used, even then if the hate bar on the other DPS is too small (exception for Monk due to being somewhat slow starters) don't use on them, or simply wait a bit before buffing people.

One thing is to check the gear, Raid Gear and/or Sophia weapon should indicate good players, still this doesn't mean they aren't bad, might be someone who got A12S weapon for a Job he doesn't play and is giving it a try.

In the end yes, for Astro is kinda hit and miss without parser.

Yeah, there are definitely a few queues, but nothing concrete. Hate meter is notoriously unhelpful vs say AoE. If we are fighting 5 mobs and a melee single targets for 1k DPS and I AOE for 3k DPS, I am doing 3x the damage, but have 60% of the hate on the mob the melee is targeting.

There is also issues such as pets reducing your hate - Garuda does ~20-25% of the damage on single target, so there is a constant 20-25% reduction in my personal hate generation. Then there are also differences with hate reductions skills.

Finally, this also requires that the AST be targeting the mob, where they may be targeting the tank and want to just quickly toss out the card.

[RobbieH]

Yeah, there are definitely a few queues, but nothing concrete. Hate meter is notoriously unhelpful vs say AoE. If we are fighting 5 mobs and a melee single targets for 1k DPS and I AOE for 3k DPS, I am doing 3x the damage, but have 60% of the hate on the mob the melee is targeting.

There is also issues such as pets reducing your hate - Garuda does ~20-25% of the damage on single target, so there is a constant 20-25% reduction in my personal hate generation. Then there are also differences with hate reductions skills.

Finally, this also requires that the AST be targeting the mob, where they may be targeting the tank and want to just quickly toss out the card.

But in this case you'd want to use the buff on whatever Job is better at AOE DPS, it's still a hit and miss but there are guaranteed gains if the person is doing AOE even if poorly.

Just to be sure, make sure they used AOE skills before buffing them.

[Kaurie]

But in this case you'd want to use the buff on whatever Job is better at AOE DPS, it's still a hit and miss but there are guaranteed gains if the person is doing AOE even if poorly.

Just to be sure, make sure they used AOE skills before buffing them.

It's just not necessarily true. Some people are truly terrible at their AoE. This is why a parser would be useful.

[JunseiKei]

But in this case you'd want to use the buff on whatever Job is better at AOE DPS, it's still a hit and miss but there are guaranteed gains if the person is doing AOE even if poorly.

Just to be sure, make sure they used AOE skills before buffing them.

I've seen ninjas and dragoons out AoE DPS a summoner. I wish I were kidding. I had to ask my husband, hey, is this person really pulling this, or did it break? Well, it wasn't broken.

[RobbieH]

I've seen ninjas and dragoons out AoE DPS a summoner. I wish I were kidding. I had to ask my husband, hey, is this person really pulling this, or did it break? Well, it wasn't broken.

I just went into Bismarck Roulette, 3 wipes we didn't beat it, Summoner didn't summon pet a single time, was spamming ruin 2 lol

Anyway, i'm going to say again, putting it on someone who is doing AOE DPS even if badly is still a gain.

[dragonseth07]

I just went into Bismarck Roulette, 3 wipes we didn't beat it, Summoner didn't summon pet a single time, was spamming ruin 2 lol

Anyway, i'm going to say again, putting it on someone who is doing AOE DPS even if badly is still a gain.

Out of curiosity. The SMN you just mentioned, would you feel justified in kicking them?

[Kaurie]

Anyway, i'm going to say again, putting it on someone who is doing AOE DPS even if badly is still a gain.

I am going to say it again, that isn't necessarily true. I've seen SMN AoE with 1000 DPS, and most melee can easily outdo 1000 DPS in single target damage. I used SMN here, because obviously they are the best at AoE - it's worse with other jobs. While yes, of equal skill, a person doing AoE will gain over single target, the issue is that you don't see people of equal skill in DF.

[JunseiKei]

I just went into Bismarck Roulette, 3 wipes we didn't beat it, Summoner didn't summon pet a single time, was spamming ruin 2 lol

Anyway, i'm going to say again, putting it on someone who is doing AOE DPS even if badly is still a gain.

It is, but I'd rather let the people pulling their weight feel like they were noticed and just got rewarded.