Quote Originally Posted by RobbieH View Post
Not entirely true, the Hate meter is a "hint" at who's doing more DPS, exception for openers (a bad DPS probably doesn't do a good opener to begin with) and if Quelling Strikes is used, even then if the hate bar on the other DPS is too small (exception for Monk due to being somewhat slow starters) don't use on them, or simply wait a bit before buffing people.

One thing is to check the gear, Raid Gear and/or Sophia weapon should indicate good players, still this doesn't mean they aren't bad, might be someone who got A12S weapon for a Job he doesn't play and is giving it a try.

In the end yes, for Astro is kinda hit and miss without parser.
Yeah, there are definitely a few queues, but nothing concrete. Hate meter is notoriously unhelpful vs say AoE. If we are fighting 5 mobs and a melee single targets for 1k DPS and I AOE for 3k DPS, I am doing 3x the damage, but have 60% of the hate on the mob the melee is targeting.

There is also issues such as pets reducing your hate - Garuda does ~20-25% of the damage on single target, so there is a constant 20-25% reduction in my personal hate generation. Then there are also differences with hate reductions skills.

Finally, this also requires that the AST be targeting the mob, where they may be targeting the tank and want to just quickly toss out the card.