Ok. I was doing some research and it appears that it's a framerate difference on my second monitor that appears to be the culprit. Since my main monitor has a max resolution of 1920x1080 and my second monitor is 1440x900 the game cannot handle the different resolutions at the same time. I don't have this issue in other games I play so it is most likely a bug with the game itself that this is happening. As a temporary fix to this, I've just plain turned off the second monitor while the game is being ran.