I'm still surprised that one of the primary arguments against a parser is "Well... you can't expect everyone to play optimally".

...I'm sorry, but when the WAR in my FC is out DPSing 80% of the DPS in Midas (normal) when they are of equal ilvl, it makes you start to question the competency of most DPS you run with. The PLD in my FC has out DPS'd 9 out of 10 BRDs of equal ilvl that we've been matched with in Midas (normal) while MTing too.

I don't expect any DPS to play at the God-like skill level that many anti-parser people claim the pro-parser people to play at. I do expect them to be able to beat the WAR OT and PLD MT more often than naught because that's their responsibility to the raid. Perhaps if these DPS see that their DPS is below the tank's it would encourage them to try harder.