Quote Originally Posted by Ragology View Post
How will they know who's best when they don't know anything though?
The mentor answers - to the best of their ability. If we are to presume that the mentor is not purposefully misleading the player then we have no reason to assume that the player is wasting their commendation by giving it to the mentor when they feel they are satisfied with the answer given - even if the answer is ultimately incorrect.

One would hope that another mentor would step in and guide this misinformed mentor and a polite conversation would happen where they would discuss the matter at hand and that better informed mentor would then mentor the mentor.

The commendations are not just for who gives the right answers they are a grading scale for who are the most willing and able mentors. In the above scenario, one would also hope that both mentors would get commendations.