Option to Remove the Circle Image on Skill CD

[Fevelle]

I love the new animations. The old ones were a lot harder to keep track of my Healer CDs, especially on controller.

[Niwashi]

It just looks like an issue of focusing on one point while ignoring others. There was indeed an issue that it was (in the former version) hard to see when exactly some of the longer cooldowns completed. And this change does indeed make that more obvious, so it's a win on that specific point.

Unfortunately, at the same time, it hides the icon itself which is supposed to tell us what skill is assigned to that button. If it comes down to a choice of not being certain when a button is available or not even being able to see what the button does, then I for one would like to know what the button does. Muscle memory can get a lot of it on familiar jobs, but if muscle memory was enough throughout, then we wouldn't even have icon hotbars display on the screen. It seems SE forgot what their primary purpose is.

[sanosuke001]

however, due to memory restrictions, we cannot hold data for two types of animation

Really? Memory restrictions preclude you from having one OR another animation in use at any given time? If you change the setting and remove one from main memory you can then load the other. Only one needs to be in main memory at any point in time. I don't think people who don't like the new animation want to mix-and-match so a all or nothing swap would suffice.

Now, if you meant "storage" then tell the PS3 kids to get bigger hard drives.

[S-r-ex]

Now, if you meant "storage" then tell the PS3 kids to get bigger hard drives.

By 3.2 the low capacity release PS3's are already screwed unless updated. Mind that the PS3 has a meager 256MB of both system and graphics memory. That wasn't much a decade ago, and still isn't much. This option might just be the drop that spills over.

[Niwashi]

Now, if you meant "storage" then tell the PS3 kids to get bigger hard drives.

By 3.2 the low capacity release PS3's are already screwed unless updated. Mind that the PS3 has a meager 256MB of both system and graphics memory. That wasn't much a decade ago, and still isn't much. This option might just be the drop that spills over.

Sanosuke's point was that this option can't be the drop that spills over because it doesn't add even a drop. There is no extra memory requirement by offering multiple options of how to display something, because regardless of how many other options a player could have chosen from, only the one they actually do choose will get loaded into memory. Hiroshi Minagawa's claim that "due to memory restrictions, we cannot hold data for two types of animation" is total baloney because the machine's memory wouldn't be holding data on both types of animation, it would only hold one or the other.

Both types would be held within the application's data files, of course, so there could be a slight increase in hard drive storage space, but the storage of an extra cooldown animation would be pretty trivial compared to the amount of other new stuff that's continually added and loaded into everyone's system regardless of which pieces of it they're actively using. And in any case, hard drive space isn't a major limiting factor on any of the platforms the game runs on since they all allow for hard drive upgrades. (PS3, for instance, which is where the memory limitations are so stringent, can use a hard drive of over two terabytes, roughly a hundred times the size of FFXIV.)

[Nutz]

Sanosuke's point was that this option can't be the drop that spills over because it doesn't add even a drop. There is no extra memory requirement by offering multiple options of how to display something, because regardless of how many other options a player could have chosen from, only the one they actually do choose will get loaded into memory. Hiroshi Minagawa's claim that "due to memory restrictions, we cannot hold data for two types of animation" is total baloney because the machine's memory wouldn't be holding data on both types of animation, it would only hold one or the other.

I'd love to tell you that you're right about that because it seems so sensible, however, he explained exactly why that is not the case. It may seem to be poor implementation, and perhaps it is, but the implementation that they are using according to the dev post is an entire packet of hotbar images all loaded at once such that every conceivable icon that could be on a hotbar (and as such any recast animations) are all held in memory at once. He mentioned that there are some exceptions, presumably for icons that change (MNK's chakra perhaps) or for whatever reason don't need to be in memory and for which some display lag would be acceptable. Something that would be called every couple of seconds at least in battle doesn't qualify.

I can't tell you why the recast animation can't stand alone outside of the packet of other hotbar icons or anything, just that the dev post specifically said that it can't and I have to believe he knows something that I don't.

On another note, I do wish they had just put a 0% saturation filter over the icon while it was on cooldown. The circles do obscure the image enough that if you're at all confused about the icon or placement on your hotbar you'll have (more) problems. I experienced this yesterday coming back from a fairly long break from the game. I was wrestling with muscle memory telling me one thing but visually being unable to confirm what certain icons were (without hovering over them to read). A minor annoyance that will probably pass, but I think there would be better ways of indicating something is on cooldown (even to the last millisecond) than obscuring the image this much.

I sympathize though. I'd like grayscale images for abilities that are on cooldown and other people may think that's a terrible idea.

[GleepWurp]

I''m definitely having more trouble seeing the cooldowns with this new adjustment than I was before. Would love to disable it.

[Dzian]

Need to remove the circles entirely. The greyed out boxes with the recast counter in the corner for me. would have been enough.

the circles block out the entire icons even more so on smaller ui scales. i'ts not so bad if I put my hotbars upto 110% or more but that makes them massive.

The numbers are great. It's just the circles that need to go. or be optional

also wonder how 90% of the testers approved the design if they also bought up the same issues?

[Warlyx]

oh come on remove the circle and put the CD timer in the middle instead.... i beg u!



just using "that" game because more players know about it....but the CD timer on the middle has been a thing for what? 12 years?

some1 asked 2 years ago this on reddit..........the answer was : U CANT



now we have numbers....and are so small that u can barely see ....plus a circle moving that distract u from this cooldown timers...

im sad , the patch is awesome and im enjoying the game , but come on why everything needs to be so complicated or cumbersome in this game ?

[dark494]

I quite like the circle and recast numbers where they are. It's a huge visual improvement for myself and many of my friends and FC members.