It was an interesting read, but even knowing the effort being put into it the circles are still quite annoying. The little numbers in the corner are okay, but I'd really like to be rid of those circles.
It was an interesting read, but even knowing the effort being put into it the circles are still quite annoying. The little numbers in the corner are okay, but I'd really like to be rid of those circles.
Whoever your testers are.... they need to be replaced.
This is horrible UI design in general. Too much going on, circle, Greyed time animation thing, and countdown..... ffs. Could have just made the original cooldown animation darker and put the countdown in the center. Everyone would have been happy.

Are people having this much trouble adapting that a dev had to step in and explain the decision making behind this all the way to it's technical aspects? Holy f... how about we all give it a few days to even try adjusting to it first?
Who knows, maybe the current design benefits new players more than appeasing some of us who refuse change because it's the easy way. As anyone who has worked a bit on his UI weeks after playing on default can tell you: even small changes which will definitely improve the experience later on will make it harder to play... for a while. Give. It. Time.
tl;dr: Get good and stop saying 4:3 is better than 16:9.


Getting good has nothing to do with this.
Motion and light changes can literally draw unwanted attention and disrupt focus for some people. This was for all intentions and purposes, feedback, even the dev was welcoming it. I doubt anyones refusing change...
Git gud and stop making assumptions.
That my friend, is called Attention-Deficit Disorder.Getting good has nothing to do with this.
Motion and light changes can literally draw unwanted attention and disrupt focus for some people. This was for all intentions and purposes, feedback, even the dev was welcoming it. I doubt anyones refusing change...
Git gud and stop making assumptions.
It's now into day three and I've already adapted to completely ignoring anything but the number count down on my UI. Unless you have severe ADD you should be able to adapt to it over time.
I'm in the camp of liking the new design. On the old design I would often click a skill, then click again thinking I missed click just to realize it wasn't ready yet. In this new design all I have to do is make a cursory glance across my bars to see what is ready, and in the case of a full circle just a quick glance to see how much time is left for it to be ready. My eyes are free to pay more attention to the the party bar for skills and spells to help the party as well as watching the enemies' cast bar. This design has really freed up my eyes for other use and allows me to plan my skills better during fights.


I really like the circles, but based on the responses here, my opinion isn't a popular one. This should become an option.



Here's what I love about this debacle:
1. They wanted to make things easier to see, esp. for people with visual problems so they added the white circles.
2 But now the white circles flash a lot...which makes it harder on some other people with other visual problems (like problems with strobes).
3. They added a toggle countdown timer anyway...
...so why didn't they just keep old icon w/ new toggable countdown overlay as an option?
I skimmed the dev post...look I get everything eats up resources...but could you maybe consider, if you can't change it otherwise, making the circles NOT WHITE? I'm not 100% sure what color would be easy to notice, but not taxing on the eyes...maybe even just shade them gray a bit...but part of the 'flashy-ness' is the white color.
-Signed
Someone that doesn't do well with constant strobing effects.




I'm in the "10%" (in quotes because I have a feeling it's more than 10% who don't like the change). I absolutely hate the new recast timers. It's very distracting. If given the option, I'd want it to return to the way it was before. Now it's just convoluted and confusing.
As a healer, I was able to keep track of what was on cooldown before, because they were the icons that looked different than the rest. Now everything is just moving with circles on them and I can't see because of all this garbage in the way.
Kindred - www.kindredlinkshell.com • My XIVPad - http://www.xivpads.com/?profile/1592...onsong/balmung

I like the circles and numbers, would it have been nice to have it in the middle? Sure. Do I need it? No.
"It's really distracting" If circles spinning at the bottom of your screen is distracting, you should probably think about controlling your ADD.
"It hurts my eyes" Its white and grey, and on the side of the screen, pay attention to the middle.
"It makes it hard to see what skill it is" You put it on the hotbar in that spot, but you don't know what it is?!?!
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.

Reply With Quote




