Thread: 3.2 Astrologian Changes

Originally Posted by Ghishlain

It's not, but SCH is insane on the MP restoration front anyway.

If you want to ask if AST can sustain MP while DPSing like a WHM, probably it can (especially now)

With this change, yes. Previously, no. Speaking only from speed running dungeons. No idea on Alexander.

Originally Posted by BloodPact

With this change, yes. Previously, no. Speaking only from speed running dungeons. No idea on Alexander.

Yeah, I was speaking from a raid perspective. WHM MP vs AST MP in mass speed pulls for 4 man's will vary from the type of tank, skill of the tank, and skill of the healer.

Originally Posted by NamoNanamo

I'm sure they did the change for a good reason.
But maybe for the next savage ? I don't care and it's always welcome.
That's not the point anw. I wast just pointing that if someone doesn't agree/understand with you doesn't mean he didn't do Savage. Unless you got some scientist fact that prove your point, you don't need to say that.

AST's enmity issues have been well known and documented since Heavensward. Initially it wasn't a big problem because of their lower potency heals, but when those got raised to WHM levels it magnified the issue. Not my fault if this is news to you, or the person who felt it wasn't some pressing issue to address.

Originally Posted by Ghishlain

I feel like they made that adjustment to LA for enmity reasons (higher up time for quelling effect).

If that's the case I hope they adjust the potency value of LA to have a similar MP restoration value as the previous 15s version. I don't feel ASTs had much MP issues to begin with and this level of MP restoration feels a bit much.

It looks like a lot, but that's a maximum of three extra tics. I think one more tic, if extended? But that buff (forget its name at the moment) is on a long cooldown.

It definitely helps alleviate issues for the most MP-starved healer, but it hardly tips the scales. You still have Assize and Freecure. No need to feel threatened.

Hmmm my problem is redraw may help with not drawing the same card... But who to say it wont do this?

Draw > spire > redraw > ewer
Draw > spear > redraw > bole
Draw > ewer > redraw > spire

We all know we fishing for Arrow, balance cards

Spear is only good for mech, bard, ninja, party(prepull) or self if ur using cooldowns etc

Bole.. Yeah cool a throw on tank forget card xD

I think it be awsome if they gave the cards more diversity rather then this

ewer/spire = mostly royal road folder or thrown for resource management
Bole = tanks enough said
Spear = mech /bard /ninja/ drg /self or aoe prepull
Balance = all dps (fishing card)
Arrow = blm (infinite resource + scales insane with speed)

So please focus the cards theb ast be awsome

Originally Posted by Mirili

It looks like a lot, but that's a maximum of three extra tics. I think one more tic, if extended? But that buff (forget its name at the moment) is on a long cooldown.

It definitely helps alleviate issues for the most MP-starved healer, but it hardly tips the scales. You still have Assize and Freecure. No need to feel threatened.

Didn't feel threatened at all. It's a nice change but one that I felt was unnecessary in terms of MP management. Like I said earlier, if it was for enmity management, I could see why they did it.

Many people keep bringing up Assize without realizing that the vast majority of the AST healing toolkit costs 10% less MP to use compared to their WHM counterpart. It's a small nuance that gets lost in the discussion when comparing MP tools. Consider it an MP passive directly on the AST healing kit.