DPS checks vs mechanics

[SnugglesD]

Thats not what i said, but well... whatever, you will turn around words anyway to fit it as you wish...
It may helps to read the whole and not just pickup pieces...
Indeed i am thinking that "good games" are where i have gotten "best memories"...
It would be strange to call games where i have gotten "best memories" as "bad games"...
Edit: And those "best memories" were in games with no DPS checks, do you get the connection?!

This is actually an argument that I have quite often with people. Just because you like something, it doesn't make it good. It is possible to recognize that something is bad and still like it. Some of my favorite movies are horrible movies from an objective stand point. Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle? Terrible movie, but one of my favorites. A Knight's Tale? Bad movie that I can enjoy every single time it comes on. Objectivity goes a long way.

[Yukiko]

This is actually an argument that I have quite often with people. Just because you like something, it doesn't make it good. It is possible to recognize that something is bad and still like it. Some of my favorite movies are horrible movies from an objective stand point. Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle? Terrible movie, but one of my favorites. A Knight's Tale? Bad movie that I can enjoy every single time it comes on. Objectivity goes a long way.

Human beings are the sum of experiences made through life, if you argue now with "everything is relative" we can perish being humans...
You can say its my opinion and its subjective but i do not force it on anyone. I never said you are playing bad games!
What i said was "as if..." and then i have even given a reason what was meant with "good game" from this viewpoint.
Now if you try to change the viewpoint but keeping the said parameters it will not work...

Lets draw a line from point A to point B to point C to point D... a Square when we look from top, a line when we look from sides...