Quote Originally Posted by Thunda_Cat_SMASH View Post
If you DO want to maximize DPS, you have the Warrior MT, and the other tank go OT. THAT is actually maximizing group DPS. A paladin or Dark Knight MT isn't maximum DPS, it's always been Warrior MT for maximum DPS.
Flatly incorrect.

DRK deals more damage as a main tank than as an off-tank, because a main tank DRK deals all the damage of an off-tank DRK, plus whatever extra damage you get out of Reprisal and Blood Price.
WAR deals more damage as an off-tank than as a main-tank, because as an off-tank they need to replace zero Fell Cleaves with Inner Beasts, and as an off-tank they can reserve Vengeance, Raw Intuition, and Infuriate purely as Abandon-generators without needing to save them for mitigation.

If A > B and C > D, then there is no way that B + D > A + C, regardless of whether or not D > A.