Zitat Zitat von Aenarion Beitrag anzeigen
so I can't talk objectively? I must join one fanboy camp or the other? lolz-logic.

old system is better for inventory space and aesthetics, but horrible for economy
new system is good for economy, but you have to to carry more pieces if you do multiple crafts and is more restrictive

It doesn't really get any clearer than that.1w
Optimal system is better overral because the economy functioned with Optimal system already regardless, and materia is a pretty big stimulus package on its own, without burdening people with restrictions. The materia and durability systems also encourages you to wear gear within your level range because deterioration/spiritbond rate does (or should) relate to optimal level.

Artificial restrictions make no sense unless you're trying to annoy everyone, then they do make sense.