The value of Carve and Spit.

[Syzygian]

What do you guys crit with C&S? Seems inferior to fel cleave. Especially When war's can triple fel cleave. Ive seen over 10k fc but never over 5k C&S. Halp please!

FC vs C&S is not a fair comparison. The former is stance dependent, on the gcd, and resides on a job whose dps is primarily in percentage based offensive buffs. The latter is off the gcd, independent of stance, and resides on a job whose dps lies in its higher base potencies and off-gcds.

That said, a 10K cleave is something that requires buffs/debuffs on yourself/the target. A carve with similar modifiers is probably only going to achieve 5-6K due to lack of a Berserk-style cooldown. Carve not costing a GCD makes up for this IMO.