You brought up bloodbath buddy not me. Maybe don't include useless information in your post if it has nothing to do with your post in the first place? You were drawing comparisons between mug and bloodbath and then wanna backtrack you dont want mug to have similar healing potencies like wtf why bother mentioning bloodbath in the first place then? You still have recouperate and access to second wind not to mention shadeshift. Bloodbath isn't gonna be the ability that you're gonna be like "oh sh*t imma die let me pop bloodbath to survive this." Mug is just an ogcd damage ability thats supposed to give you extra chance at additional items if your farming mats or something outside. A treasure hunter ripoff from XI basically with the added bonus that it does dmg. The healing part is just some tacked on nonsense that doesnt even sound like it should be included in the ability in the first place so maybe if it didn't have the healing part at all you would feel better? Haymaker doesnt make much sense either you gonna lobby to change that as well? Maybe Dark Passenger too?
It was wrong then and they did it anyway so why not repeat it basically is what you are saying? Sorry I dont agree with this logic.
Again it was stupid then, and yet you wanna go ahead and repeat that? For what purpose? As some sort of reparation? I guess your reasoning would be:
Monk was crap for a while and we feel bad so lets go and buff them even further now even though we already fixed its previous problems (and even though they dont need further buffs to be in line with the other melee) just as reparation for all the suffering they endured in the past.
That's how it works now lol? Continue to ignore bigger problems to "fix" an ability (mug) who's main application when developed was likely to imitate treasure hunter for mat farmers and not to be some incredibly useful pvp ability? Yeah, no. FFXIV is not the place to start practicing affirmative action policies. Not every ability in the game is gonna be incredibly useful. Believe it or not some are just niche abilities.