Pay for:
-The servers up until 2.0
-Moderators to deal with problem players (between now and 2.0)
-Patches 1.20, 1.21, and 1.22.
-The one-time storyline leading up to the Seventh Umbral Era.

Why is anyone arguing about this?

If that's not worth your $13/month, then take it elsewhere. Find somewhere you're happy. I really don't understand why so many people are coming on these forums to rage at all us "fanboys" "fangirls" and "white knights" who are deciding to pay (and continuing to post after their message is delivered).

I also don't understand calling people freeloaders for deciding it's not worth their money.